Tesla Board's Independence Is Tested by Musk's Buyout Idea - Canadanewsmedia
Connect with us


Tesla Board's Independence Is Tested by Musk's Buyout Idea



A buyout plan for Tesla would be highly complex, putting added pressure on its board.


mike blake/Reuters

The people tasked with overseeing

Elon Musk’s

plans for


TSLA -4.83%

—its board of directors—have received solid support from shareholders over the years but criticism from some investors and advocates who say they lack independence.

Boards have enormous responsibility in corporate deals, especially ones as complex and fraught as the buyout of Tesla that Mr. Musk suggested this week. Most of Tesla’s directors have close business or personal relationships with Mr. Musk that they would have to balance against their obligation to ensure that any deal serves the interests of Tesla shareholders beyond its famous leader, corporate governance specialists say.

The board’s role in the possible buyout was clouded by Mr. Musk’s unusual way of announcing the idea—in a sudden, very brief tweet on Tuesday. That tweet was followed more than 20 hours later by a short statement from six directors saying the board had met several times since Mr. Musk told it of his go-private idea last week, and that it was “taking the appropriate next steps to evaluate this.”

The sequence of events suggests that “the board review has been very, very informal,” said Adam Epstein, who heads corporate-governance consultant Third Creek Advisors.

Mr. Musk’s announcement attracted scrutiny from the Securities and Exchange Commission, which has asked Tesla whether Mr. Musk was truthful when he said in his tweet that he had secured funding for the buyout.

Tesla didn’t respond to requests for comment on the SEC queries.

On Thursday, Tesla shares fell for a second straight day to $352.45, leaving them below their level before Mr. Musk’s announcement and about 16% under the $420 target price he set for a buyout of the electric-car maker.

Tesla’s board has nine members. Mr. Musk, who owns about a fifth of Tesla, is chairman as well as chief executive. He and his brother, Kimbal, are the only directors the board doesn’t label as independent.

Tesla says that it evaluates numerous factors in determining directors’ independence, including their commercial, accounting, legal, banking, consulting, charitable and familial relationships.

Several other directors are close to Mr. Musk, including

Brad Buss,

who was previously chief financial officer at SolarCity, the renewable energy company Mr. Musk led and that Tesla acquired in 2016.

Lead independent director

Antonio Gracias,

founder of Valor Equity Partners, has invested in several Musk ventures going back to


which Mr. Musk co-founded. He was a SolarCity director and is a director at Mr. Musk’s rocket company, Space Exploration Technologies Corp., or SpaceX. The Musk brothers have invested with Valor, according to Tesla’s proxy statement.

Ira Ehrenpreis,

who heads Tesla’s compensation committee and its nominating and governance committee, also is a SpaceX investor, as is

Steve Jurvetson,

a venture capitalist who is on leave from Tesla’s board. Both have been associates of Mr. Musk for years.

Messrs. Gracias, Buss and Ehrenpreis didn’t respond to requests for comment. Mr. Jurvetson declined to comment about the proposed deal and didn’t respond to questions about the board’s independence.

Board independence has received more attention in recent years. Governance specialists point out that regulatory requirements for independence have limited scope.

Todd Henderson, professor at the University of Chicago Law School, says the value of independence can be overstated. Still, he says following normal procedure for cases like Tesla’s—such as forming a special committee on the board to consider the buyout—would improve the reception for any deal.

Boards normally play active roles overseeing major transactions, and in management-backed buyouts their importance can be greater because directors must negotiate against CEOs on behalf of other shareholders.

Six months before PC-maker Dell announced founder

Michael Dell’s

plan to take the company private in 2013, its board formed a special committee to negotiate terms with him, according to company filings. When the deal was announced it came with a detailed financing plan including backing from the equity sponsors and debt underwriting from Wall Street banks. Afterwards the board clashed with Mr. Dell and his partners as directors sought a higher price for shareholders. They won a slight increase.

Shareholder advocates have frequently challenged Tesla’s board, with little success.

Glass Lewis, one of two major shareholder advisory services, strongly opposed the proposal for Tesla to buy SolarCity, calling it a “thinly veiled bail-out plan” and saying the Tesla board was “rife with conflicts.” Shareholders approved the deal.

Last year, under pressure from shareholders including California State Teachers’ Retirement System to add two independent directors, Tesla announced the addition of

James Murdoch,

CEO of

21st Century Fox


Linda Johnson Rice,

CEO of Johnson Publishing Co. (21st Century Fox and News Corp, parent company of The Wall Street Journal, share common ownership.)

This year, when Mr. Murdoch was up for re-election, Glass Lewis and rival adviser Institutional Shareholder Services recommended against him, saying he had too many other board and executive commitments to provide effective oversight. Mr. Murdoch was re-elected with 90% of the votes.

A spokeswoman for Mr. Murdoch declined to comment. Ms. Johnson Rice, who wasn’t up for reelection, didn’t respond to an email.

Also this year, the Tesla board’s compensation committee—composed of Mr. Buss, Mr. Gracias, Mr. Ehrenpreis and

Robyn Denholm,

chief operating officer of Telstra Corp.—recommended a 10-year compensation package for Mr. Musk that Tesla valued at $2.6 billion. Tesla said the package would incentivize Mr. Musk to remain and would help Tesla achieve its goals.

The two advisory services both blasted the proposal, with ISS saying “the grant value is unprecedented and sets the new high-water mark for an individual executive equity award at a U.S. public company.”

Shareholders approved the package in March with 85% of the vote.

Write to Rolfe Winkler at rolfe.winkler@wsj.com

Let’s block ads! (Why?)

Source link

Continue Reading


Musk Defends Relentless Work Hours as Tesla Enters Fateful Week




Terms of Service Violation

Your usage has been flagged as a violation of our terms of service.

For inquiries related to this message please contact support.
For sales
inquiries, please visit http://www.bloomberg.com/professional/request-demo

If you believe this to be in error, please confirm below that you are not a robot by clicking “I’m not a robot”

Please make sure your browser supports JavaScript and cookies and
that you are not blocking them from loading. For more information you can review the Terms of Service and Cookie

Block reference ID:

Let’s block ads! (Why?)

Source link

Continue Reading


Several anti-pipeline protesters released from BC jail days before week-long sentences end




Several pipeline protesters were released from a British Columbia jail on Sunday, a few days before their week-long sentences were set to end.

Seven protesters in all were sentenced to a week-long jail term on Aug. 15, after pleading guilty to contempt charges in B.C. Supreme Court.

Five who were released on Sunday issued a joint statement, saying they were imprisoned because of their opposition to the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion.

Story continues below advertisement

In the statement, the five women – who include anti-poverty activist and Order of Canada recipient Jean Swanson – said they are not criminals, but “political prisoners.”

Swanson said in a phone interview that her four days spent at the Alouette Correctional Centre for Women in Maple Ridge, B.C., had not deterred her in what she said is a fight against climate change.

“I don’t know how anyone can look at the sky in Vancouver today and say global warming is not an issue,” said Swanson, in reference to the smoke and particulate matter from wildfires hazing the skies in southwestern B.C.

“We need to do something, we need to stop the insanity.”

From her perspective as an anti-poverty advocate, Swanson said the Trans Mountain pipeline ties the issues of homelessness, poverty and climate change together.

“For all those billions and billions of dollars, governments could actually create jobs building renewable energy…. Governments could end homelessness, they could put clean and safe water on Indigenous reserves.”

In May, the federal government announced its intent to acquire Trans Mountain from Kinder Morgan Canada.

Story continues below advertisement

Story continues below advertisement

According to recent documents filed with the U.S. Security and Exchange Commission, the sale could cost as much as $1.9-billion more than the initial quote of $4.5-billion.

The documents also suggest the project could take another 12 months to finish.

More than 200 activists have been arrested for demonstrations against the Trans Mountain project since March.

Those released on Sunday also included former B.C. Teachers’ Federation president Susan Lambert.

Let’s block ads! (Why?)

Source link

Continue Reading


Online pot sales will leave a lot of information at risk, say experts




TORONTO — Buyers who have to provide personal information to purchase recreational pot online after legalization this fall should be able to rely on existing laws to protect their privacy but the issue needs to be watched closely to ensure regulations are obeyed and mistakes are avoided, experts say.

The matter is important given the stigma many people still attach to marijuana use, and the potential for Canadians to be barred from the United States if their otherwise legal indulgence becomes known to American border agents.

“We need to keep eyes on it, meaning we have to make sure this information is not abused or used for secondary purposes that were never intended,” Ann Cavoukian, Ontario’s former privacy commissioner and now an expert at Ryerson University, said in an interview. “Theoretically, it should not be used for any other purpose.”

A spokesperson for federal Privacy Commissioner Daniel Therrien said the office had not looked specifically at online marijuana sales. At the same time, the commission said it recognized privacy concerns around buying or using marijuana given its longtime status as a controlled substance.

“The legal sale and use of both medicinal and recreational marijuana raises privacy issues, particularly since laws and regulations differ from country to country and even within countries,” Tobi Cohen said. “We have repeatedly raised concerns about the effectiveness of (Canada’s two privacy laws) in the digital age and have called for both laws to be strengthened.”

Last week, Ontario’s new Progressive Conservative government announced that consumers 19 years or older will have to go online to buy weed after legalization federally on Oct. 17 because private retail stores won’t be up and running until April. A government agency called the Ontario Cannabis Store will run the online sales, although private e-commerce provider Shopify will be involved.

Online buyers will, at minimum, have to provide a name along with email and delivery address, and payment information. In Ontario, as is currently the case with online alcohol sales, buyers will be able to order as a “guest” without creating an online account.

However, Scott Blodgett, a spokesperson for the Ministry of Finance, said buyers will have to provide proof of age via government-issued ID, which a delivery person will verify but not copy. The cannabis store website will have data security and privacy controls “aligned with global e-commerce best practice,” he said.

Personal data will remain in Canada and not be shared with third parties, Blodgett said.

Ontario’s Privacy Commissioner Brian Beamish was unavailable to discuss the issue but his office said in a statement that public institutions are accountable for the information they collect.

Let’s block ads! (Why?)

Source link

Continue Reading


Copyright © 2018 Canada News Media

%d bloggers like this: