Andrew Berry, the Vancouver Island man accused of killing his two daughters on Christmas Day 2017, has been found guilty of two counts of second-degree murder.
The jury delivered the verdict Thursday after 18 hours of deliberation, which began Tuesday afternoon.
Gasps could be heard throughout the Vancouver courtroom as the verdict was read. Berry stared at the floor, saying nothing in response.
Berry was found in his Oak Bay apartment laying in the bathtub with several stab wounds. His daughters, six-year-old Chloe and four-year-old Aubrey Berry, were found stabbed to death in their beds.
Crown argued Berry’s wounds were self-inflicted and he had killed his daughters after hitting rock bottom over a crippling gambling addiction that made him unable to pay his bills.
Prosecutors and witnesses had told the court Berry was fearful his financial state would lead to him losing custody of the girls to his ex-partner, who he resented.
Both Berry and his defence have maintained the father was attacked by a person connected to a loan shark named “Paul” to whom he owed a significant gambling debt, and woke up later to discover his daughters had been killed.
Berry had testified he took the girls sledding Christmas Eve and Christmas morning until that afternoon when a “dark-skinned” man attacked him.
Defence had suggested the real killer was allowed to get away after police failed to secure the crime scene immediately.
Crown had compared defence’s case to “a plot from a low-budget movie,” pointing out DNA from a fourth person was never found in Berry’s apartment.
They instead suggested Berry killed the girls in the morning, then turned the knife on himself with intentions to die.
The court heard Berry had spent years falling deeper and deeper into debt from gambling, to the point where the power would be cut off at his home.
His ex-partner Sarah Cotton testified she grew increasingly worried that people were out to “get” Berry because of his debts.
A custody dispute dating back to 2013 had been mostly resolved shortly before the killings, with a judge granting Berry parental visits, including the one on Christmas Eve.
Police discovered Berry and the girls’ bodies during a welfare check at Berry’s apartment, after Cotton reported he was late dropping their daughters off at her home as scheduled.
News of the girls’ deaths sent shock waves throughout Oak Bay and the rest of Greater Victoria. People traveled from mainland B.C. to Vancouver Island for several vigils in the days following the murders.
Berry faces a mandatory life sentence, with a minimum 10 years before becoming eligible for parole.
—With files from Rumina Daya