With some frequency, Wall Street professionals use this phrase: “Bad news for the economy is good news for the stock market.” They also use it in reverse, with good news for the economy said to be bad for stocks.
At first glance, whichever way you read it, the line might seem to make little sense. Many people see the economy and the stock market as inextricably linked. In their minds, if the economy is weakening, then surely company profits will suffer, which will end up sending stock prices lower. But that’s not always the case.
Share Your Thoughts
Are there any investing terms that confuse you? Join the conversation below.
It’s only when looking deeper that things become clearer, but even then, there are some subtleties to navigate.
“A little bit of bad news is good for markets,” says
chairman and portfolio manager at Boston-based mutual-fund company Northeast Investors Trust. It all revolves around the response by the Federal Reserve to economic news. When the news for the economy is bad, such as a sudden unexpected rise in the unemployment rate, then it is less likely that the Fed’s monetary-policy committee will raise the cost of borrowing money—a key variable for both business and consumer finances. That tends to help keep prices for stocks and bonds buoyant, Mr. Monrad says.
But too much bad news is indeed bad for stocks. “The bad news can’t be so bad that it brings into question future earnings,” Mr. Monrad says. For instance, in the early days of the Covid-19 pandemic, news of the global viral outbreak sent markets into a tailspin starting around mid-February 2020 through late March. The S&P 500 index dropped more than 30% over that period, in anticipation of the pandemic’s economic impact. The U.S. economy shrank at an annualized rate of 31% in the second quarter of last year, government statistics show.
Currently, the U.S. economy is looking strong, and that means the Fed is likely drawing closer to raising interest rates. “Fed officials continue to tilt hawkish,” says a recent report from New York-based investment bank Brown Brothers Harriman.
So, that’s good economic news that could be bad for stocks—but maybe not just yet. Interest rates have been so low for so long that it has long been anticipated that the next move in rates will be up. So until rates actually rise, or at least are expected to rise sooner than they are now, the market may continue to climb as the economy improves, some analysts say. And against that backdrop, bad news could lose some of its luster for the market.
“I think we should be in a place where good news is good news,” says
head of global macro strategy at Academy Securities in New York. “Right now, if we get further bad news, we might get markets going down.”
Mr. Constable is a writer in Edinburgh, Scotland. He can be reached at email@example.com.
The global economy is falling below expectations – The Economist
For a look behind the scenes of our data journalism, sign up to Off the Charts, our weekly newsletter
IT IS WELL known that markets hate uncertainty. Bad news, then, that by one measure the world economy is throwing up more nasty surprises for investors. Citigroup’s global economic-surprise index (CESI), which measures the degree to which macroeconomic data announcements beat or miss forecasts compiled by Bloomberg, has fallen into negative territory for the first time since November (the indices for America and China have been negative since mid-May). Since the summer of 2020 economic indicators had tended until recently to surprise on the upside. But as inflation has surged and consumer confidence has flagged, they are now failing to meet forecasters’ expectations. (See chart.)
Measures of economic surprises appear to be a useful way to gauge market sentiment. When the economy is booming data releases will typically be better than analysts expected, boosting the CESI. During an economic downturn, economic statistics will fall below the consensus estimate, leading to negative surprises. From June 2020 to July 2021, when the CESI for America was positive thanks to upbeat employment, inflation and housing figures, the S&P 500 index of big American firms rose by 38%. Since then the CESI has bounced above and below zero, and shares have fallen by roughly 9%.
In a paper published in 2016 Chiara Scotti, an economist at the Federal Reserve, constructed her own surprise index based on five indicators: GDP, industrial production, employment, retail sales and manufacturing output. America’s index also measured personal income. Ms Scotti found that positive economic surprises in America were associated with appreciation of the dollar relative to the euro, pound sterling and yen. (In fact, Citi’s index was designed by the bank’s foreign-exchange unit for trading currencies, not stocks.)
But the surprise index can be hard to interpret. The CESI includes both backward- and forward-looking macroeconomic indicators, and is weighted in favour of newer releases and those that tend to have the biggest impact on markets. Because the index reflects economic performance relative to expectations, it can be negative during expansions if forecasters are too optimistic, and positive during contractions if they are too gloomy. But as Citi analysts wrote in a research note, “coincident rather than causal relationships are relied on even if they have no consistency whatsoever.” ■
Sri Lanka Economy Shrinks 1.6% Amid Political Chaos, Inflation – BNN
(Bloomberg) — Sri Lanka’s economy fell back into contraction last quarter as the country battled its worst economic problems since independence, with emergency aid to stabilize the island nation proving elusive.
Gross domestic product declined 1.6% in the quarter ended March from a year earlier, the Department of Census and Statistics said in a statement on Tuesday. That’s shallower than a 3.6% contraction seen by economists in a Bloomberg survey and compares with a revised 2% expansion in the previous quarter.
The contraction likely marks the beginning of a painful and long recession for the country, whose Prime Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe last week said the economy had “completely collapsed.” The crisis follows years of debt-fueled growth and populist fiscal policies, with the Covid-19 pandemic’s hit to the dollar-earning tourism industry serving as the last straw.
Absence of foreign exchange to pay for import of food to fuel led to red-hot inflation, the fastest in Asia, triggering protests against the government led by the Rajapaksa clan that eventually led to the resignation of Mahinda Rajapaksa as premier. While the months-long protests hurt business activity in parts of the country, the government on Monday imposed new curbs, which includes a call to residents to stay home until July 10 to conserve fuel.
That will depress activity further, while raising the risk of more unrest given lingering shortages of essential goods.
Sri Lanka is in talks with the International Monetary Fund for aid to tide over the crisis, with at least $6 billion needed in the coming months to prop up reserves, pay for ballooning import bills and stabilize the local currency. The central bank has raised interest rates by 800 basis points since the beginning of the year to combat price gains that touched 39%.
Other details from the GDP report include:
- For the first quarter, the services sector grew 0.7% from a year earlier
- Industrial production slipped 4.7% and agriculture output contracted 6.8%
©2022 Bloomberg L.P.
China's economy recovering but foundation not solid, premier says – Financial Post
BEIJING — China’s economy has recovered to some extent, but its foundation is not solid, state media on Tuesday quoted Premier Li Keqiang as saying.
China will strive to drive the economy back onto a normal track and bring down the jobless rate as soon as possible, Li was quoted as saying.
“Currently, the implementation of the policy package to stabilize the economy is accelerating and taking effect. The economy has recovered on the whole, but the foundation is not yet solid,” Li was quoted as saying.
“The task of stabilizing employment remains arduous.”
China’s economy showed signs of recovery in May after slumping the previous month as industrial production revived, but consumption remained weak and underlined the challenge for policymakers amid the persistent drag from strict COVID-19 curbs.
China’s nationwide survey-based jobless rate fell to 5.9% in May from 6.1% in April, still above the government’s 2022 target of below 5.5%.
In particular, the surveyed jobless rate in 31 major cities picked up to 6.9%, the highest on record. Some economists expect employment to worsen before it gets better, with a record number of graduates entering the workforce in summer.
Li vowed to achieve reasonable economic growth in the second quarter, although some private-sector economists expect the economy to shrink in the April-June quarter from a year earlier, compared with the first quarter’s 4.8% growth.
(Reporting by Kevin Yao and Beijing newsroom; Editing by Andrew Heavens, William Maclean)
Support dogs to comfort victims at Quebec’s specialized sexual violent courts
Trudeau expected to face tough questions on Canadian military spending at NATO summit
Cyberspy agency launched operation to protect federal election from foreign attack
Silver investment demand jumped 12% in 2019
Europe kicks off vaccination programs | All media content | DW | 27.12.2020 – Deutsche Welle
Global Media Markets, 2015-2020, 2020-2025F, 2030F – TV and Radio Broadcasting, Film and Music, Information Services, Web Content, Search Portals And Social Media, Print Media, & Cable – GlobeNewswire
Tech24 hours ago
YouTuber tries to upgrade his old M1 MacBook Pro 13 to the brand-new Apple M2 processor – Notebookcheck.net
Health20 hours ago
Sudbury news: Northern agencies highlight national HIV testing day | CTV News – CTV News Northern Ontario
Tech10 hours ago
It's official: Xiaomi 12S series with Leica-tuned cameras is coming on July 4 – GSMArena.com news – GSMArena.com
Tech23 hours ago
iQOO will debut the Dimensity 9000 Plus processor in the upcoming 10-series flagship smartphones – Notebookcheck.net
Sports18 hours ago
Makar gets love from Orr after winning 2022 Norris, Conn Smythe Trophies – NHL.com
Health19 hours ago
Monkeypox case count rises to more than 3400 globally, WHO says – The Globe and Mail
Politics20 hours ago
Roe v. Wade: How abortion came to divide US politics – CTV News
Real eState22 hours ago
Calls increase for more money as Montreal and rest of Quebec facing housing crunch