Not a Bubble? The equity markets have been driven by momentum and speculation these past few weeks, not by underlying business fundamentals. We had GameStop
, followed by Silver, then Pot stocks, and now SPACs, all driven by retail. PE ratios are in the top 1% of their historical range. Junk bond yields are at all-time-record low levels (sub 4%). In January, the worst stocks based on business fundamentals, significantly outperformed the overall market. This kind of behavior is what typically occurs at market tops. Doesn’t mean it can’t last longer. And we don’t know what event(s) will cause it to turn. But it is likely true the general market will have a difficult time moving much higher, as it has already discounted an economic rebound starting in Q3.
The Labor Market
The underlying health of the economy is, and always has been, measured by the health of the labor market. By that measure, we should worry. Market pundits, those on the sell side, point to the latest Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projections, which say GDP will return to pre-pandemic levels by mid-2021 as justification for nosebleed equity valuations. Government transfer payments grew 36% in 2020. Many collecting unemployment received more than they did in their old jobs. No doubt, the Biden $1.9 trillion stimulus will positively impact GDP. But that’s like maxing out one’s credit card for current living expenses without employment income, and pretending all is well. It isn’t!
In fact, those same CBO projections set included a couple of items conveniently ignored by the business media: 1) The economy won’t reach its potential GDP (i.e., there will be economic slack) until 2025, and 2) The actual number of employed people won’t reach pre-pandemic levels until sometime in 2024. That’s three years from now! The most optimistic reading of this CBO projection is that the employment market is “healing.”
Unfortunately, the most recent data do not support the “healing” hypothesis. It appears that there has been no “net” progress in the labor market since the end of September. The first chart and table show the weekly Initial Unemployment Claims (ICs) in the state-run programs for the past 51 weeks. Data for the week of February 6 show initial claims of 813K (Not Seasonally Adjusted (NSA) because the pandemic isn’t seasonal). That looked like an improvement from the 850K of the prior week – never mind that the worst reading recorded in the Great Recession was less than 700K and that spike was relatively short lived. The market ignored the fact that the initial reading for the prior week (January 30) was 816K (the 850K number was the result of an upward revision). So, the 813K reading should be looked at through the 816K lens, which means “no real progress!” Let’s be realistic: 813K, 850K, 816K – these are all government-generated data. Remember the expression: “Close enough for government work?” Are there really any substantive differences among those numbers? Of more importance, we are nearly a year into the pandemic and there are still more than 800K layoffs per week. And, that only counts those eligible for the state programs.
The next chart and table are even more concerning. The CARES Act last April established several programs (Pandemic Unemployment Assistance (PUA)) for those not eligible for the state unemployment plans. Those programs originally expired on December 26. They were renewed by the legislation at year’s end that doled out $600/taxpayer earning less than $75K in 2019. According to Yahoo Finance, paperwork issues resulted in delays for several states (did you really expect something different?).
In this chart and table, which combines the state, PUA and other small programs, there is a significant dip in Continuing Claims (CCs) in early January. But, now, with the PUA programs re-established, we are right back to where we were at the end of October. That says to me, three months with no progress! The latest labor force level, as measured by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), was 160.1 million. Given the 20.4 million shown on the chart and in the table, that calculates to an unemployment rate of 12.7%. But wait, not long ago, the labor force level was north of 164 million. Four million have dropped out. If they are included as unemployed, the real unemployment rate is closer to 15%! Some hot economy, don’t you think?
Other High Frequency Data
Other data confirm what the labor market is telling us:
· The number of vacant housing units rose +14.9% in Q3 and +4.9% more in Q4 to more than 3 million units. Vacancy rates are above 7% in major U.S. cities. Manhattan vacancies are approaching 13,000 and rents there are down -19%. In Boston, they are down -22%.
· Retail sales were negative in October, November, and December. Johnson Redbook same store sales indicate that this negative run will likely continue.
· Mortgage applications for purchase have fallen in three of the past four weeks, and down -4.2% the week of February 5 versus the prior week. Refis are also down -4.2% for the same period. Housing has been holding up well, one of the few solid parts of the economy. And, while this negative data is new and very short in duration to this point, it could be worrisome.
As all the readers of this blog are well-aware, equity markets believe that, with the rollout of the vaccines and the $1.9 trillion stimulus on its way, “normal” will return by Q3 and the economy will “boom.” In my last few blogs, I have outlined why the “pent-up” demand narrative won’t play out as advertised (rising savings, unemployment levels, missed “services” aren’t made-up, demand for “stay at home” goods likely satiated). Besides what I outlined in those blogs, here are additional issues to ponder when thinking about the coming “boom:”
· At the end of 2020, 3.4 million mortgages were delinquent. Since the foreclosure moratorium began, consumers have used some of that mortgage payment money for consumption. While most mortgagors will likely tack the missed payments on the back end of the loan and extend its term, that mortgage money will no longer be available for consumption. Mortgagees have a much higher marginal propensity to consume (MPC) than do financial institutions or mortgagors.
· A huge 18% (10 million) of renters are behind on their rent. The eviction moratorium has been extended to March 31 and will likely be extended further. What happens when the moratorium ends? Will renters be required to pay current rent and back rent? Likely, there will be some period of “make-up.” If so, what happens to consumption and economic growth? Once again, renters have a much higher MPC than landlords. One solution I’ve heard is that the government will pay the landlords. Really? Do you think the government has the stomach to reimburse those “wealthy” landlords? (Not if Elizabeth and Bernie have anything to say!)
· There have been many surveys of how U.S. consumers have treated the recent “stimulus” checks and how they intend to treat any additional “free” monies from Uncle Sam. All come to similar conclusions:
- 30% will be used to boost savings
- 18% will be used to pay down debt
- 22% will be used to pay back rent
- Total is 70% that isn’t consumed.
· If 200 million people get $1,400 checks, that is equivalent to $280 billion. If 30% of that is used for consumption, GDP rises by $84 billion (about +0.4 pct. points). I’ve seen estimates as high as $550 billion (30% of the entire $1.9 trillion stimulus). Using the $550 billion number, that would increase GDP by about 2.75 pct. points. Likely, this is where the CBO comes up with their call that GDP will reach pre-pandemic levels by mid-year. Really, though, not much kick here!
· Bank lending has always been a good barometer of the strength of the economy. That makes sense. When businesses are growing and expanding, banks are lending. To show the state of the current economy, in 2020, three of the four largest U.S. banks saw loans and leases contract:
- BAC: -5.7%
- Citi: -3.4%
- Wells: -7.8%
- Only JPM showed higher loan balances.
Markets expect inflation to reignite and the result has been a weekly back up in Treasury rates since the start of the year. The 10-year U.S. Treasury Note yield closed at 1.21% on Friday, February 12, up from 0.93% at the turn of the year. In past blogs, I have discussed the composition of the CPI (mostly services) and the deflation occurring in rents, medical, and tuition (45% of “Headline” CPI and 55% of “Core” CPI). With rents deflating, wages barely growing because of an oversupply of labor, and bank credit contracting (including credit card balances), it is quite difficult for significant inflation to appear. (There may be inflation in some commodity prices because of the difficulty in transportation, but they have a very small influence on the CPI.) In addition, given the levels of debt now in the corporate world, especially in the “zombie” companies (defined as those companies whose cash flows are inadequate to pay their debt service) (zombies now comprise 20% of the S&P 500), rising interest rates raise debt service costs and further siphon off profits.
Of course, interest rates can continue to rise (just as the equity markets can) as long as there is buy-in to the narrative that an economic “boom” will begin in Q3. But, eventually, reality will set in and those rates will come back down. You can also count on the Fed to limit any rate increases. Powell has indicated that in very plain English.
Equity markets continue to display “market top” behavior. Based on historical data, forward returns are likely to be muted.
Labor markets have recently shown renewed stagnation. There has been no progress in the labor market since October. Other high frequency data confirm the continuance of economic stagnation.
In addition, undiscussed in the media are the issues surrounding the impact of mortgage delinquencies, missed rents and stagnation in bank lending on economic growth.
The debt markets have semi-adopted the renewed inflation narrative, and rates have risen and may continue to do so in the near-term. Economic reality and the Fed will eventually reverse this trend. Lower for longer!
India's economy expands 0.4% in Oct.-Dec., ending recession – North Shore News
NEW DELHI — India’s economy expanded by a weaker-than-expected 0.4% in the October-December quarter, which still allowed it to escape recession following large contractions in the two previous quarters during the coronavirus pandemic, the government said Friday.
The National Statistical Office projected an 8% contraction for the 2020-21 financial year, which ends in March. In January, it had projected a contraction of 7.7% for the fiscal year, following 4% growth in 2019-20.
It said fertilizer production rose by 2.7% in January, steel by 2.6% and electricity generation by 5.1%. Coal production declined by 1.8%, crude oil by 4.8% and natural gas by 2%, it said in a statement.
India’s economy contracted by 7.5% in the July-September quarter following a record plunge of 23.9% in the previous three months. The government had imposed a strict two-month lockdown across the country in March after the outbreak of the pandemic.
A country enters a technical recession if its economy contracts in two successive quarters. India’s recovery is expected to improve with a rise in consumer demand and investment.
India’s central bank, the Reserve Bank of India, is projecting gross domestic product growth of 10.5% in financial year 2021-22. The International Monetary Fund has projected 11.5% growth in calendar 2021.
The IMF estimated that the Indian economy contracted 8% in 2020.
The Associated Press
Boost to Household Income Primes U.S. Economy for Stronger Growth – The Wall Street Journal
France's economy shrinks more than forecast – MarketWatch
The French economy’s contraction in the fourth quarter of 2020 was slightly more pronounced than previously estimated, data from the country’s statistics agency Insee showed Friday.
In the October-December period, gross domestic product shrank 1.4% from the previous quarter–0.1 percentage point more than the preliminary estimate of a 1.3% contraction released on Jan. 29.
GDP in the quarter contracted 4.9% from a year earlier, the data showed. The decline was 0.1 percentage point less than the 5% drop previously estimated.
The French economy–the eurozone’s second largest–is expected to contract again in the first quarter of 2021, as extended government restrictions to contain the coronavirus hinder economic activity.
Write to Xavier Fontdegloria at email@example.com
CPP Investments CEO Mark Machin resigns after travelling to UAE for COVID-19 vaccine – CTV News
Pouce Coupe mayor in hot water regarding posts on her social media page – CKPGToday.ca
About Last Night: Even in defeat, the Canadiens aren't 'worried' about Carey Price – Montreal Gazette
Silver investment demand jumped 12% in 2019
Iran anticipates renewed protests amid social media shutdown
Galaxy M31 July 2020 security update brings Glance, a content-driven lockscreen wallpaper service
Economy22 hours ago
B.C. economy set to grow in 2021, 2022, forecast suggests
Health11 hours ago
Canada sees good news about COVID-19 inoculations as doses arrive more quickly
Economy11 hours ago
Canada’s finance ministry calls report of CPPIB CEO’s overseas trip for COVID shot ‘very troubling’
Business13 hours ago
Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce profit beats estimates on capital market strength
Health4 hours ago
CPPIB CEO Mark Machin steps down after getting COVID-19 vaccine in UAE – Global News
Real eState13 hours ago
RBC Adds Two “Severe” Risk Scenarios, Including Canadian Real Estate
Media13 hours ago
Information posted on Chinese social media platforms could be used for 'hostile activities,' Bill Blair warns – National Post
Health13 hours ago
'Total hell': PSW describes working through COVID-19 outbreak at Ont. long-term care home – CTV News