The two-person Ottawa-area staffing company that has received millions of dollars in federal commissions on IT projects subcontracted its work on the ArriveCan app to six other companies, including multinationals such as BDO and KPMG, new documents reveal.
They also show the pay rates that GCstrategies billed the government, which are often in the range of $1,000 to $1,500 per day, per worker. The company has said it keeps a commission of between 15 and 30 per cent.
For months, neither the company nor the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) that led the project would reveal the identity of the subcontractors who worked on the ArriveCan app, saying it is confidential third-party information.
MPs studying the issue – including both Liberal and opposition members – told The Globe the new information raises important questions as to why the government turned to a two-person company that charges significant commissions rather than dealing with the larger companies directly or performing the work in-house.
“It’s an atrocious abuse of public dollars,” said NDP MP Matthew Green, who described the arrangement as disrespectful to the public service. “Here we are shovelling money out the back door to people who are running businesses out of their basements. It is scary.”
The Globe and Mail first reported in October that federal spending on the app is on track to exceed $54-million this fiscal year and that the small company that received the most federal work on the app – GCstrategies – relies on a network of subcontractors to deliver on its federal contracts.
The ArriveCan app was initially created in early 2020 as a way for travellers to upload mandatory health information related to COVID-19 to present when crossing the border. The app is no longer mandatory as of Sept. 30, but it continues as a voluntary option.
The CBSA has said the cost of the app began as an $80,000 expense but the bill for the app and its maintenance grew to $54-million, from more than 70 updates to keep up with changing public health guidelines.
The Globe reports on ArriveCan prompted an investigation by the House of Commons committee on government operations, which ordered the company and federal departments to hand over related documents such as contracts. The responses have been arriving in waves and in many cases have been heavily redacted.
Previous releases of government records included pages of invoices submitted by GCstrategies that left committee members with the impression that the company had put together a team of independent IT contractors to deliver on its ArriveCan commitments.
However, the new documents provided to the committee by the company shed light in terms of where the individual IT workers came from and how much GCstrategies billed the government for their work.
The new documents include written agreements between GCstrategies and six other companies to perform the ArriveCan work. They include BDO Canada LLP; Optiv Security Inc./Optiv Canada Inc.; KPMG LLP; Macadamian Technologies Inc.; Level Access and Distill Mobile Inc.
One document describes $8.3-million in payments to the six subcontractor companies from GCstrategies covering the period of June, 2022, to July, 2022. However the CBSA said that is a typo and should read June, 2020, to July, 2022.
The chart says Distill Mobile Inc. received $5.1-million of that amount, followed by $1.8-million for Macadamian Technologies Inc. Payments to the four other companies were all under $1-million.
Distill Mobile describes itself on its website as an Ottawa-based technology company founded in 2011.
“Need to create an app?” its website asks. “Or perhaps you’ve got a project that needs some senior development expertise to take it to the next level. Whatever it is you need, we can help.”
Four of the six listed subcontractors did not provide a statement in response to The Globe’s questions. A spokesperson for KPMG responded to say the company can confirm it was contracted by GCstrategies. The work was performed by KPMG employees and one independent consultant, the company said. BDO said it cannot discuss client affairs with third parties.
The Distill Mobile contract is dated Dec. 8, 2019, and says the company will work on “multiple mobile applications.” The CBSA has previously said existing contract work with GCstrategies was shifted to include ArriveCan at the onset of the pandemic.
Reached by phone on Friday, Distill Mobile founder Tom Murphy said he was not interested in discussing the matter.
The contract letter between KPMG and GCstrategies’ Kristian Firth is dated Oct. 8, 2021, and is described as “private and confidential.” It says KPMG will provide a security assessment and privacy safeguards.
In a statement to The Globe, CBSA spokeswoman Rebecca Purdy said the agency was not aware that all six companies were involved as subcontractors and said the agency is reviewing its contracting policies.
The statement said the agency was operating from “an emergency posture” and it was unclear how long the additional contract workers would be needed to maintain the app and its many updates.
“The CBSA did not know which companies GCstrategies used to get the workers – the agency’s main focus at the time was to get the people needed to support the app. The CBSA acknowledges this raises questions relating to the business model. These questions are forming part of our own after action review.”
Ms. Purdy said the contract with GCstrategies did not require the company to disclose the identity of any companies that were hired as subcontractors.
GCstrategies’ contracts with CBSA committed the company to using individuals with approved federal security clearance, which is managed by another department, Public Services and Procurement Canada.
Like previous rounds of documents filed with the committee, the records from GCstrategies continue to redact the identities of the individual workers on the project.
The committee called the two GCStrategies partners – Darren Anthony and Mr. Firth – to testify in October after The Globe and Mail’s reporting.
Mr. Firth told MPs they are the company’s only employees and they both work from home. The company does not have separate office space.
They described themselves as an IT staffing firm and said neither of them perform IT work themselves. Further, they said they have received about $4.5-million a year, or about $9-million as of March 31, 2022, to work on the ArriveCan project.
Mr. Firth also said the company has invoiced a total of $44-million in federal contract work with more than 20 departments over the past two years. They said they charge a commission of between 15 and 30 per cent of contract values for their services, meaning they have been paid millions of dollars in recent years to hire temporary workers for federal departments.
In an e-mailed statement Friday, Mr. Firth said he and his company have always been clear about their confidentiality obligations.
“At all times before, during and after my testimony before the committee we were truthful, open and honest,” he said. “After my testimony, GCstrategies was ordered by the committee to produce all documentation that we possessed related to the committee’s work, under threat of contempt of Parliament proceedings if we failed to deliver everything. We did so only after receiving assurances from the committee that the materials we delivered were to be treated confidentially and redacted to protect personal information. We continue to do our best to comply with all of our legal obligations.”
Mr. Firth said the decision to use independent subcontractors, another company or a mix of the two depends on the needs of each client.
Liberal MP Anthony Housefather had previously defended redactions related to subcontractors because he said they appeared to be individual IT workers acting as temporary employees of GCstrategies. He is a committee member and the parliamentary secretary to Public Services and Procurement Minister Helena Jaczek.
In an interview, he said the fact that GCstrategies subcontracted the work to other companies, including multinationals, raises questions.
“I didn’t know that they had contracted with five or six entities to supply individuals. But it’s all the more reason, I believe, for us to seriously look at the question of whether or not we need this type of company as an intermediary. And shouldn’t there be human resources specialists in the Government of Canada that go out and find personnel?” he said.
Opposition MPs said the new information raises more questions as to why federal departments are using GCstrategies.
Conservative MP Michael Barrett said in an interview that the government is essentially using GCstrategies as a “shield” to protect the identities of the companies receiving tax dollars and to avoid taking responsibility for the problems with the app.
“It’s a bit beyond belief that the government would hire a two-person firm and then have no interest or detail on who was doing any of the subcontracting work, particularly when you talk about the sensitivity of the information that was going to be handled by this app,” he said. “It’s an attempt by the government to mitigate or minimize their accountability and responsibility for the failures of the ArriveCan app, and for the ballooning costs.”
Mr. Green, the NDP MP, said if companies are getting federal work as subcontractors, that information is not normally disclosed, meaning the public and Parliament won’t have accurate full tallies of how much each company is receiving in federal contracts.
“It begs the question: Where else are these big multinationals being involved in procurement under the guise of subcontractors?” he asked. “I think it requires a full review. And I think it also begs the question around the information that we receive from the government. Why does the government continue, in the access to information process, to obscure, block and redact information that ought to be made publicly available?”
In addition to its study of ArriveCan spending, the government operations committee is also investigating the growth of federal spending on outsourcing and the increasing use of the global consulting firm McKinsey & Company.
Fuel made from Russian oil is being funneled to New York – Markets Insider
[unable to retrieve full-text content]
- Fuel made from Russian oil is being funneled to New York Markets Insider
- Oil’s New Map: How India Turns Russia Crude Into the West’s Fuel BNN Bloomberg
- Indian refineries ditch US dollar to buy Russian oil amid Ukraine sanctions – report Hindustan Times
- Oil’s new map: how India turns Russian crude into the West’s fuel South China Morning Post
- Analysis | What Europe Risks With Wider Sanctions on Russian Oil The Washington Post
- View Full Coverage on Google News
Indian tycoon Adani hit by more losses, calls for probe
NEW DELHI (AP) – Trading in shares in troubled Adani Enterprises gyrated Friday as the flagship company of India’s second-largest conglomerate tumbled 30% and then rebounded after more than a week of heavy losses that have cost it tens of billions of dollars in market value.
The debacle, which led Adani to cancel a share offering meant to raise $2.5 billion, has drawn calls for regulators to investigate after a U.S. short-selling firm, Hindenburg Research, issued a report claiming the group engages in market manipulation and other fraudulent practices. Adani denies the allegations.
Opposition lawmakers blocked Parliament proceedings for a second day Friday, chanting slogans and demanding a probe into the business dealings of coal tycoon Gautam Adani, who is said to enjoy close ties with Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
“We have no connectionâ€³ with the Adani controversy, Parliamentary Affairs Minister Pralhad Joshi told reporters outside Parliament on Friday.
In an interview with CNN News 18, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman brushed off concerns that the losses would spook global investors and said India’s financial market was “very well regulated.”
“As a result, the investors’ confidence which existed before shall continue even now,” she said, adding that the controversy wasn’t “indicative of how well Indian financial markets are governed.”
Amit Malviya, the governing Bharatiya Janata Party’s information and technology chief, said in a television interview that the opposition was using Adani’s crisis to target the Modi government over a private company’s shares and their market movements. “Regulators are looking into” what happened, he said.
The market watchdog, the Securities and Exchange Board of India, has not commented. The Economic Times newspaper reported, citing unnamed SEBI sources, that it had asked stock exchanges to check for any unusual activity in Adani stocks.
Shares in Adani Enterprises fell as much as 30%, to 1,017 rupees ($12), on Friday. At the end of trading, the price had recovered to 1,531 rupees ($18.70) but was still down by 2%. The company’s share price has plunged more than 50% since Hindenburg released its report last week, when it stood at 3,436 rupees ($41). Stock in six other Adani-listed companies were down 5% to 10% on Friday.
So far there has been no indication that the company’s woes might threaten the wider financial sector in India. Its equities market is large enough to sustain the fallout at this moment, said Brian Freitas, a New Zealand-based analyst with Periscope Analytics who has researched the Adani Group.
“Adani stock forms a small part of the equities market and investor concerns right now are restricted to the company, not the whole system or market itself,” Freitas said. India’s Nifty and Sensex indexes were both higher on Friday.
It could take time for problems to surface, Shilan Shah of Capital Economics said in a report. “From the macro perspective there are few signs of contagion,” he said. “But it is too early to sound the all clear.”
The S&P Dow Jones indices said Thursday it would remove Adani Enterprises from its sustainability indices beginning Tuesday, following a “media and stakeholder analysis triggered by allegations of stock manipulation and accounting fraud.”
That might dent the Adani Group’s sustainability credentials and could affect investor sentiment, Freitas said.
Adani, who made a vast fortune mining coal and trading before expanding into construction, power generation, manufacturing and media, was Asia’s richest man and the world’s third wealthiest before the troubles began with Hindenburg’s report.
By Friday, his net worth had halved to $61 billion, according to Bloomberg’s Billionaire Index, where he dropped to the 21st spot worldwide.
He has said little publicly since the troubles began, though in a video address after Adani Enterprises canceled its already fully subscribed share offering he promised to repay investors. The company has said it is reviewing its fundraising plans.
Hindenburg’s report said it was betting against seven publicly listed Adani companies, judging them to have an “85% downside, purely on a fundamental basis owing to sky-high valuations.” Other issues in the report included concerns over debt, alleged use of offshore shell companies to artificially raise share prices and past investigations into fraud.
Adani’s speedy, debt-led expansion in recent years caused his net worth to shoot up nearly 2,000%. Even before last week, critics said his ascent was aided by his apparent close ties to Modi and his government. Analysts say he has been successful at aligning his priorities with those of the government by investing in key sectors, but point out that he also has major infrastructure projects in states that are ruled by opposition parties.
“The question now turns to the future of the Adani Group and how they will grow,” said Aveek Mitra, founder of Avekset Financial Advisory.
As a company heavily involved in infrastructure — from airports and ports to highways — it needs financing to grow in order to service its debt, which stands at $30 billion, out of which $9 billion is from Indian banks.
Adani may be able to sell some assets and continue its expansion, but at a much slower pace than earlier, Mitra said.
“Banks, financial institutions and investors will think five times before investing now,” he added.
Associated Press writer Ashok Sharma contributed to this report.
Ottawa expands price caps to Russian petroleum products to reduce revenues
The department says the maximum price for seaborne Russian-origin petroleum will be US $100 per barrel for “premium-to-crude” products as of Sunday, and US $45 for “discount-to-crude” products.
It says in a press release the new caps build on a Russian crude oil price limit announced in December, adding both moves will weaken President Vladimir Putin’s ability to fund the war against Ukraine.
The Department of Finance says the caps will be enforced by prohibiting buyers who do not abide by the price caps from obtaining services from companies in the G7 or Australia.
It says the price cap mechanism has been designed to reduce Russian revenues while recognizing the importance of stable energy markets and minimizing negative economic effects.
Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland says Russian oil revenues have already declined since the first price cap took effect and the additional price caps “will be another blow to Putin’s war chest.”
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Feb. 4, 2023.
This story was produced with the financial assistance of the Meta and Canadian Press News Fellowship.
The Canadian Press
I'm a parent with an active social media brand: Here's what you need to check on your child's social media right now – CNN
Fuel made from Russian oil is being funneled to New York – Markets Insider
How Real Estate Investor in Chicago Scaled up and Built Wealth – Business Insider
Silver investment demand jumped 12% in 2019
Iran anticipates renewed protests amid social media shutdown
Search for life on Mars accelerates as new bodies of water found below planet’s surface
News22 hours ago
Tobogganing rules in some Canadian cities draw criticism
Media22 hours ago
Canada adds Russian media personalities, companies in latest round of sanctions – CP24
Business23 hours ago
Elon Musk cleared of fraud in Tesla Twitter case – CTV News
News20 hours ago
Extreme cold temperatures across Quebec, East Coast expected to linger until Sunday
Media15 hours ago
Why social media makes you feel bad
Business21 hours ago
Adani crisis ignites India contagion fears, credit warnings – Al Jazeera English
Business14 hours ago
Indian tycoon Adani hit by more losses, calls for probe
News23 hours ago
Ontario teen wins $48m lotto jackpot on first try