Connect with us


The Rogers-Shaw deal will make the Liberals nervous in an election year



Prime Minister Justin Trudeau participates in a news conference on the COVID-19 pandemic in Ottawa, March 12, 2021.

Justin Tang/The Canadian Press

The first order of business is to stall. The next thing the Liberals have to figure out is how bad a political beating they will take if they approve the Rogers-Shaw deal. Or even if they just leave it hanging in the air during an election campaign.

Ordinarily, this kind of transaction – Rogers Communications Inc.’s $20.4-billion bid for rival Shaw Communications Inc. – would raise a few weak questions from government, slow-but-certain reviews and, eventually, public acquiescence.

But this deal, at this time, is a political problem for the governing Liberals.

This time, it is connected to the public’s sensitivity to the high costs of cellphone service, a Liberal campaign promise that hasn’t gone very far, and an expected federal election this year.

It’s worth remembering that in the 2019 election campaign, the Liberals promised to lower Canadians’ mobile-phone bills by 25 per cent – but only as a defence against the NDP, which was promising heavier regulation, including price caps, to make wireless plans more affordable.

That’s a pretty good indicator of the politics. Nearly everyone gets a mobile-phone bill, nearly everyone gets annoyed by it, and a lot of folks want government to do something about it. Some want the government to regulate prices, and those who don’t want Ottawa to foster competition.

The Liberals’ 2019 promise to lower Canadians’ wireless phone bills by 25 per cent within two years comes due this fall. But they haven’t done much other than redefining the way it is measured, to allow it to claim progress – by focusing on certain low-data phone plans offered by the telephone companies’ discount brands.

Now, the proposed Rogers-Shaw transaction would see one of the Big Three wireless companies – Bell, Rogers and Telus – buy out the fourth. For years, Liberal and Conservative governments have pursued the strategy of encouraging a fourth company that would force the Big Three to compete and lower prices. But Shaw is just the latest challenger to be bought out.

That makes approving the deal politically tricky for the Liberals. They are already taking a beating on all sides.

The NDP wants the Liberals to kill the transaction, arguing it would allow an oligopoly to consolidate and further “gouge” consumers. “I think people are going to start asking some hard questions,” New Democrat MP Brian Masse said in an interview.

Conservative industry critic Pierre Poilievre called for parliamentary hearings on the deal, saying his party would put the interests of consumers and workers ahead of the “corporate interests” of a “protected, regulated oligopoly.”

Cutting to the chase, Mr. Poilievre said his party won’t accept a reduction in the number of national players to three from four: Either the deal must be rejected, or conditions must be attached to the approval that would allow a fourth player to emerge. That second option would happen only if Rogers is forced to forgo some of Shaw’s assets, like wireless-spectrum licences, or some of its own.

So what do the Liberals do now? Stall. Killing a $20-billion transaction in a slow economy would be a big call. But it’s also risky to approve this one in a likely election year.

The government got a heads-up about the deal only Sunday night, according to John Power, a spokesman for Innovation Minister François-Philippe Champagne.

The Liberals are already noting that Rogers’ acquisition of Shaw has to be approved by the Competition Bureau, the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission, and the Department of Innovation, Science and Economic Development.

The government will spin that it will judge the deal on affordability, competition and innovation. The companies will argue the expanded entity will be able to invest in 5G and will expand broadband networks. Maybe, given the glacial pace of CRTC reviews, the Liberals could hide behind pending reviews through a 2021 election. But maybe not.

If there is an election in June or October, you can expect the NDP to attack the Liberals on failing to act on wireless phone bills, and for failing to stop a few big rich companies from gaining a tighter stranglehold on the market. And the Liberals and NDP often fish in the same pool of voters. You can bet there are already Liberals in Ottawa who think there is more political upside in killing the deal than approving it.

Certainly, Canadian politicians know it’s not a vote-winning strategy to run as the friend of the phone company.


Source:- The Globe and Mail

Source link

Continue Reading


Almost half of Shopify’s top execs to depart company: CEO



By Moira Warburton

(Reuters) – Three of e-commerce platform Shopify’s seven top executives will be leaving the company in the coming months, chief executive officer and founder of Canada‘s most valuable company Tobi Lutke said in a blog post on Wednesday.

The company’s chief talent officer, chief legal officer and chief technology officer will all transition out of their roles, Lutke said, adding that they have been “spectacular and deserve to take a bow.”

“Each one of them has their individual reasons but what was unanimous with all three was that this was the best for them and the best for Shopify,” he said.

The trio follow the departure of Craig Miller, chief product officer, in September. Lutke took on the role in addition to CEO.

Shopify, which provides infrastructure for online stores, has seen its valuation soar in the last year as many businesses went virtual during COVID-19 lockdowns. It has a market cap valuation of C$182.7 billion ($146 billion), above Canada‘s top lender Royal Bank of Canada.

It is Canada‘s biggest homegrown tech success story, founded in 2006 and supporting over 1 million businesses globally, according to the company.

“We have a phenomenally strong bench of leaders who will now step up into larger roles,” Lutke said, but did not name replacements.

Shopify said in February revenue growth would slow this year as vaccine rollouts encourage people to return to stores and warned it does not expect 2020’s near doubling of gross merchandise volume, an industry metric to measure transaction volumes, to repeat this year.

Chief talent officer, Brittany Forsyth, was the 22nd employee hired at Shopify and has been with the company for 11 years. She said on Twitter that post-Shopify she would be focusing on Backbone Angels, an all-female collective of angel investors she co-founded in March.

Shopify shares fell 5.1% while the benchmark Canadian share index ended marginally down.

($1 = 1.2515 Canadian dollars)


(Reporting by Moira Warburton in Toronto; Editing by Aurora Ellis)

Continue Reading


CANADA STOCKS – TSX falls 0.14% to 19,201.28



* The Toronto Stock Exchange’s TSX falls 0.14 percent to 19,201.28

* Leading the index were Stantec Inc <STN.TO​>, up 3.4%, Imperial Oil Ltd​, up 3.3%, and Corus Entertainment Inc​, higher by 2.9%.

* Lagging shares were Aphria Inc​​, down 14.2%, Village Farms International Inc​, down 9.9%, and Aurora Cannabis Inc​, lower by 9.4%.

* On the TSX 91 issues rose and 134 fell as a 0.7-to-1 ratio favored decliners. There were 24 new highs and no new lows, with total volume of 228.0 million shares.

* The most heavily traded shares by volume were Toronto-dominion Bank, Royal Bank Of Canada and Suncor Energy Inc.

* The TSX’s energy group fell 0.32 points, or 0.3%, while the financials sector climbed 2.46 points, or 0.7%.

* West Texas Intermediate crude futures rose 0.52%, or $0.31, to $59.63 a barrel. Brent crude  rose 0.4%, or $0.25, to $63.2 [O/R]

* The TSX is up 10.1% for the year.

Continue Reading


Air Canada signs C$5.9 billion government aid package, agrees to buy Airbus, Boeing jets



By David Ljunggren and Allison Lampert

OTTAWA/MONTREAL (Reuters) -Air Canada, struggling with a collapse in traffic due to the COVID-19 pandemic, reached a deal on Monday on a long-awaited aid package with the federal government that would allow it to access up to C$5.9 billion ($4.69 billion) in funds.

The agreement – the largest individual coronavirus-related loan that Ottawa has arranged with a company – was announced after the airline industry criticized Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s Liberal government for dawdling. The United States and France acted much more quickly to help major carriers.

Canada‘s largest carrier, which last year cut over half its workforce, or 20,000 jobs, and other airlines have been negotiating with the government for months on a coronavirus aid package.

In February, Air Canada reported a net loss for 2020 of C$4.65 billion, compared with a 2019 profit of C$1.48 billion.

As part of the deal, Air Canada agreed to ban share buybacks and dividends, cap annual compensation for senior executives at C$1 million a year and preserve jobs at the current level, which is 14,859.

It will also proceed with planned purchases of 33 Airbus SE 220 airliners and 40 Boeing Co 737 MAX airliners.

Chris Murray, managing director, equity research at ATB Capital Markets, said the deal took into account the “specific needs of Air Canada in the short and medium term without being overly onerous.”

He added: “It gives them some flexibility in drawing down additional liquidity as needed.”

Transport Minister Omar Alghabra said the government was still in negotiations with other airlines about possible aid.

Canada, the world’s second-largest nation by area, depends heavily on civil aviation to keep remote communities connected.

Opposition politicians fretted that further delays in announcing aid could result in permanent damage to the country.

Air Canada said it would resume services on nearly all of the routes it had suspended because of COVID-19.


The deal removes a potential political challenge for the Liberals, who insiders say are set to trigger an election later this year.

The government has agreed to buy C$500 million worth of shares in the airline, at C$23.1793 each, or a 14.2% discount to Monday’s close, a roughly 6% stake.

“Maintaining a competitive airline sector and good jobs is crucially important,” Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland told reporters, adding the equity stake would allow taxpayers to benefit when the airline’s fortunes recovered.

The Canadian government previously approved similar loans for four other companies worth up to C$1.billion, including up to C$375 million to low-cost airline Sunwing Vacations Inc. The government has paid out C$73.47 billion under its wage subsidy program and C$46.11 billion in loans to hard-hit small businesses.

Michael Rousseau, Air Canada‘s president and chief executive officer, said the liquidity “provides a significant layer of insurance for Air Canada.”

Jerry Dias, head of the Unifor private-sector union, described the announcement as “a good deal for everybody.”

Unifor represents more than 16,000 members working in the air transportation sector.

But the Canadian Union of Public Employees, which represents roughly 10,000 Air Canada flight attendants, said the package protected the jobs of current workers rather than the 7,500 members of its union who had been let go by the carrier.

($1=1.2567 Canadian dollars)

(Reporting by David Ljunggren in Ottawa and Allison Lampert in Montreal; Additional reporting by Julie Gordon in Ottawa and Munsif Vengattil in Bengaluru; Editing by Dan Grebler and Peter Cooney)

Continue Reading