As Canada and other countries try to deal with their respective affordable housing challenges, a Dutch cabinet minister recently attempted to even the playing field and expand home ownership among the less wealthy.
Housing Minister Hugo de Jonge had proposed a law that would have allowed municipalities to force homeowners, whose homes were worth up to $355,000 Euros (about $517,000 Cdn) to put their property on the market only to low and middle-income earners.
That meant local governments could refuse to grant residency permits to wealthy potential buyers and keep them out of the market for homes up to that value
The problem the policy is trying to fix is one that’s particularly acute in Canada, said Jeremy Withers, the outreach co-ordinator for the University of Toronto’s School of Cities Affordable Housing Challenge Project.
“And that problem is that prospective first-time buyers are finding it increasingly difficult to compete in bidding wars for housing,” said Withers, who is also a PHD candidate in the department of Geography & Planning at the University of Toronto.
WATCH | Trudeau encourages municipalities to set ‘ambitious’ housing targets:
Trudeau encourages municipalities to set ‘ambitious’ housing targets
1 month ago
Duration 0:24
Addressing the Federation of Canadian Municipalities, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau discusses working with municipalities to tackle the housing crisis and create transit infrastructure.
Housing issues in Canada
Over the past decade, Withers said, a fast-growing share of housing has been bid up and acquired by higher income Canadians who already own their homes but are building up portfolios of investment properties.
For example, 45 per cent of Ontario condo apartments and 18 per cent of Ontario houses are not owner occupied, he said, citing Statistics Canada data.
“I think policies that aim at curtailing demand from kind of wealthy, high income bidders would likely help to mitigate continuing rise in prices and wealth inequality that’s really come to define Canada’s private housing system.”
De Jonge’s proposal, while initially looking like it might have support in parliament, was ultimately defeated, but not before stirring up controversy and opposition for infringing on the property rights of homeowners.
The proposal by Dutch Housing Minister Hugo De Jonge, seen speaking to media in The Hague in May 2022, was ultimately defeated, but not before stirring up controversy and opposition for infringing on the property rights of homeowners. (Lex Van Lieshout/AFP/Getty Images)
Still, Dutch proponents of the law echoed Withers’ comments, noting that much cheaper houses are now out of reach for people with an average salary.
“Now house seekers in a village are outbid by people from outside who have a lot of money to spend,” Christian Union party member Pieter Grinwis told the Netherlands’ AD newspaper.
Although Canada faces a similar issues, some housing experts here questioned whether such measures are the right approach.
“For the Canadian context, what we need more fluidity in the market, not more constraints,” said Mathieu Laberge, an government advisor at KPMG and former chief economist at the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation.
WATCH | Investors dominate Canada’s condo market:
Investors make up big share of Canada’s condo market, new data shows
5 months ago
Duration 1:49
Recent Statistics Canada numbers show investors own a big share of the country’s condo market, as much as 42 per cent in some parts of Ontario, adding another hurdle for first-time home buyers trying to enter the market.
‘Unforeseen negative consequences’
“When you look in the literature, coercive approaches, they’re well intentioned, but they tend to bring in unforeseen negative consequences,” Laberge said.
“I think it would set up a whole lot of disincentive. If you own a house in this spectrum and now you see a large portion of your potential buyers forbidden to buy, why would new home owners enter this market?
Paul Anglin professor of real estate at the University of Guelph, questioned some of the practical aspects of the Dutch proposal, and whether it would just cause housing prices to rise.
“If I were a seller, I would tend to choose a list price above the limit. Doing so would remove the constraint,” he said in an email.
“If the goal of the proposal is to improve the social goal of fairness, should the law account for the income of the seller also?”
Subsidies, building housing, co-ops
Anglin suggested that the responsibility for housing affordability is being dumped on the home owner.
“A solution which is administratively simpler than this proposal would be to use tax money to directly subsidize purchases by people who are deemed worthy,” he said.
Toronto city councillor Brad Bradford, who is also chair of the Planning & Housing Committee, said the solution to the housing affordability crisis isn’t more bureaucracy, or having the government decide who is allowed to buy someone’s house.
“The solution is to build more homes, so people have more options to rent or buy at different price points,” he said in a statement. “The city needs to streamline approvals and eliminate unnecessary rules and guidelines to get more housing built faster.”
Toronto city councillor Brad Bradford, who is also chair of the Planning & Housing Committee, said the solution to the housing affordability crisis isn’t more bureaucracy, but rather building more homes. (Nav Rahi/CBC)
Laberge believes there should be more focus on initiatives like co-ops — rental apartments where a collective of tenants are the owners of the building and where some people pay a higher rent to enable more affordable units for those who need them.
“We used to have a bunch of co-ops,” Laberge said. “Co-ops are successful worldwide in terms of providing affordable housing, but somehow Canada departed from co-ops in the early ’80s. That’s something we could revisit.”
Withers said that while he supports the Dutch idea of addressing the issue of demand and inequality, he was unclear how exactly the mechanics of the proposal would work.
Taxation on investors
He suggested that in Canada, a better way to open the housing market to less wealthy prospective buyers would be through taxation on investors.
That could include increasing the capital gains tax on money made when investors sell residences, or requiring an additional land transfer tax for buyers who already own multiple properties, he said.
LISTEN | Pinning housing hopes on a market crash:
Front Burner19:21Is a housing crash an affordability fix?
As some prospective home buyers watched prices climb to dozens of times their income during the pandemic, they pinned their hopes of ownership on a market crash. And for nearly a year starting last April, prices did fall – in Toronto, the average price of a home dropped about 18%. But now, for the last two months, prices have been on the rise again. So with houses still historically unaffordable, what would it take for Canada’s home prices to drop or crash toward affordability, and would the economic damage do more harm than low prices can help? Today, Canadian Center for Policy Alternatives senior economist Marc Lee explains the paths that remain to ownership for the low and middle class. For transcripts of this series, please visit: https://www.cbc.ca/radio/frontburner/transcripts
As well, Withers suggested that local investors who don’t plan to live in the homes they buy could be made to pay the same taxes that foreign investors face when purchasing units.
“And this would discourage them from outbidding prospective homeowners,” he said.
OTTAWA – The Canadian Real Estate Association says the number of homes sold in August fell compared with a year ago as the market remained largely stuck in a holding pattern despite borrowing costs beginning to come down.
The association says the number of homes sold in August fell 2.1 per cent compared with the same month last year.
On a seasonally adjusted month-over-month basis, national home sales edged up 1.3 per cent from July.
CREA senior economist Shaun Cathcart says that with forecasts of lower interest rates throughout the rest of this year and into 2025, “it makes sense that prospective buyers might continue to hold off for improved affordability, especially since prices are still well behaved in most of the country.”
The national average sale price for August amounted to $649,100, a 0.1 per cent increase compared with a year earlier.
The number of newly listed properties was up 1.1 per cent month-over-month.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Sept. 16, 2024.
MONTREAL – Two Quebec real estate brokers are facing fines and years-long suspensions for submitting bogus offers on homes to drive up prices during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Christine Girouard has been suspended for 14 years and her business partner, Jonathan Dauphinais-Fortin, has been suspended for nine years after Quebec’s authority of real estate brokerage found they used fake bids to get buyers to raise their offers.
Girouard is a well-known broker who previously starred on a Quebec reality show that follows top real estate agents in the province.
She is facing a fine of $50,000, while Dauphinais-Fortin has been fined $10,000.
The two brokers were suspended in May 2023 after La Presse published an article about their practices.
One buyer ended up paying $40,000 more than his initial offer in 2022 after Girouard and Dauphinais-Fortin concocted a second bid on the house he wanted to buy.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Sept. 11, 2024.
MONTREAL – The Quebec Professional Association of Real Estate Brokers says Montreal-area home sales rose 9.3 per cent in August compared with the same month last year, with levels slightly higher than the historical average for this time of year.
The association says home sales in the region totalled 2,991 for the month, up from 2,737 in August 2023.
The median price for all housing types was up year-over-year, led by a six per cent increase for the price of a plex at $763,000 last month.
The median price for a single-family home rose 5.2 per cent to $590,000 and the median price for a condominium rose 4.4 per cent to $407,100.
QPAREB market analysis director Charles Brant says the strength of the Montreal resale market contrasts with declines in many other Canadian cities struggling with higher levels of household debt, lower savings and diminishing purchasing power.
Active listings for August jumped 18 per cent compared with a year earlier to 17,200, while new listings rose 1.7 per cent to 4,840.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Sept. 6, 2024.
