Rustad’s Nuremberg, Nazi comparisons to COVID-19 measures ‘regrettable,’ says Eby

MAPLE RIDGE, B.C. – British Columbia’s election campaign was dragged far off course Monday as the two main party leaders were forced to comment about comparisons of the Nuremberg trials of Nazi war criminals to COVID-19 pandemic health measures.

Vandalism at the property of a Vancouver billionaire, who erected a large sign critical of B.C.’s New Democrats, also diverted leaders off their messages.

The controversial comparisons supporting a Nuremberg-like investigation of B.C. COVID-19 health officials, and the spray-paint vandalism of Lululemon founder Chip Wilson’s property come as the leaders prepare for Tuesday’s televised debate, which signals a critical juncture of the campaign.

NDP Leader David Eby, B.C. Conservative Leader John Rustad and Green Party Leader Sonia Furstenau will face each other under the glare of lights during the only televised debate of the campaign.

Rustad apologized Monday for his prior comments about the Nuremberg trials and COVID-19 measures that “offended some people.”

“My comments in and around that relating in any way relating to the two, I apologize for that,” he said at a news conference in downtown Vancouver. “That certainly was not my intent with regards to that issue.”

Rustad posted a statement on social media Sunday to “clarify” his comments after video surfaced with him saying his party would “certainly be participating with other jurisdictions.”

Rustad made the comments after being asked at an online meeting in July about where he stood on “Nuremberg 2.0,” in reference to an idea that those behind public health measures established during the pandemic should be put on trial.

The B.C. Conservative leader said in a statement on the social media platform X that he “misunderstood the question” about whether he supported “Nuremberg 2.0.”

He said it’s a “distortion of history” to compare pandemic public health measures with Nazi Germany or the Nuremberg trials, which sought accountability for the Holocaust.

He said he made the comments during a conversation with members of the BC Public Service Employees for Freedom group.

Rustad was in Vancouver to layout his party’s platform around public safety near the site where a man’s hand was severed in an attack last month.

He promised a Conservative government would create a new court to handle minor offences and hire more judges, sheriffs and front line police officers, while also ending the province’s decriminalization of small amounts of certain illicit drugs.

Eby called Rustad’s comments “regrettable,” at a news conference in Maple Ridge where he announced plans to build a new school in the community and promised to increase child care workers and classroom counsellors at B.C. public schools.

“To be entertaining suggestions that we would put public health officials, doctors and nurses who ran vaccine programs, who responded in the depths of the pandemic, on trial similar to Nazi war criminals, is shameful. It’s bizarre,” he said. “It’s really regrettable.”

The issue is the latest in a series of unscripted moments on the campaign, which also included the erection of a large sign outside Wilson’s Vancouver home last week, calling the NDP “communist.”

Photos on social media show the sign and the gates to Wilson’s $81-million home vandalized with crude graffiti about the athletic clothing apparel founder.

Vancouver Police say they’re investigating after receiving a report.

Eby said the sign on Wilson’s property is a symbol of the political divide in this election.

“The sign on Chip Wilson’s property, it reflects whose side John Rustad’s on,” he said. “He’s on the side of Chip Wilson. He’s on the side of billionaires and the real estate speculators. I’m on the side of the people who are trying to get by who are facing higher costs and struggling in different ways.”

Eby said the issues people are facing will not be resolved with spray paint.

“The problem’s getting solved with votes,” he said.

Eby, at a campaign event at Maple Ridge, promised education plans that include a mental health counsellor in every school and an educational assistant for all classrooms from kindergarten toGrade 3.

He also said there would be expanded on-site school child care.

Greens Leader Sonia Furstenau in Victoria said the party would support what she called a successful model of transitional housing that is employed in Duncan on Vancouver Island.

She said “The Village” model, which sees people housed in small individual housing units, offers “practical solutions for the homelessness crisis.”

As the Oct. 19 election day approaches, advance voting will also be available Oct. 10 to 13 and Oct. 15 to 16.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Oct. 7, 2024.

MONTREAL – With prayers, protests, and a heavy police presence, Canada has marked the anniversary of the Oct. 7, 2023, attack by Hamas on Israel that killed about 1,200 people and triggered an ongoing war.

Children arrived at Jewish schools under police watch in cities including Vancouver and Toronto.

Mourners remembered victims of the attacks and prayed for the safe return of hostages seized by Hamas, while others demonstrated against Israel’s military action in Gaza that has killed more than 41,000 Palestinians, according to the territory’s health ministry.

Events were mostly trouble-free, but in Montreal, what began as a large and peaceful pro-Palestinian march through the city’s downtown ended with police using chemical irritants and sheer numbers to chase off a group of protesters who used metal bars to smash the doors and windows of a row house under construction belonging to McGill University.

A masked speaker with a megaphone said it was to be part of a sports science institute named after Israeli-Canadian billionaire Sylvan Adams, and urged the protesters to “take out your rage on the building.”

For the past year, the Hamas attack and the ensuing war have been at the heart of widespread protests, university encampments, and a spike in reports of hate crimes against Jews and Muslims.

In Montreal, several hundred people had gathered downtown to mark the anniversary with speeches, wreath-laying and prayers while a smattering of pro-Palestinian protesters shouted and police kept watch.

Channa Leah Natanblut, a Concordia student and one of the speakers, said Jews were hurting and mourning and it was important to deal with that sadness and show strength.

“It’s been a very hard year, but I think it’s important to show other Jews that we are not intimidated by the violence we’ve seen in the streets of Montreal … their fear tactics are not working on us,” Natanblut said.

In the separate protest march from Concordia University to McGill, some protesters ran down a side entrance onto the closed off McGill campus, knocking down a metal barricade manned by campus security.

That group was confronted by a contingent of police on horseback, before being chased back off campus by police who ran at them, banging batons on shields.

At the beginning of the march, McGill student Rama Al Malah said students were there to commemorate one year since the beginning of what she called a “mass genocidal campaign against the people of Gaza.” She said student protesters wanted to reaffirm their support for Palestinians and reiterate demands to Concordia and McGill, including divestment from companies linked to Israel’s war effort and an academic boycott of Israeli institutions.

Thousands of supporters of Israel gathered in Toronto’s north end Monday night, many of them holding photos of hostages or waving small Israeli flags.

Mayan Shavit, who lost two members of her family, an aunt on Oct. 7 and a cousin who was among six hostages killed in August, said she was in “disbelief” seeing so many people at the event.

“A year ago on Oct. 7, 2023, we woke up to a completely upside-down world,” she said. “I don’t know to what world we woke up to, but it wasn’t the world we all knew.”

Jeff Rosenthal, the chair of United Jewish Appeal-Federation of Greater Toronto, thanked local officials who attended the event, including Premier Doug Ford.

“Tonight, we come together to reflect and to remember the lives that were lost, the communities that were shattered one year ago and those remaining hostages that we so desperately want back home.”

The mother of a Montreal man killed in the Oct. 7 Hamas attacks told a gathering in that city that the events of the last year have given her family the chance to see both the best and the worst of humanity.

Raquel Look said her 33-year old son Alexandre Look died a hero while shielding others after the music festival he was attending came under attack.

“I know that Alex infused my soul with the strength to keep going, and I will work tirelessly to build a future based on peace and co-operation for all people,” she said.

Long lines formed outside a Vancouver synagogue as people attending a memorial gathering had to go through metal detectors and were scanned by security wands.

Politicians of every stripe attended the event, including NDP Leader David Eby and B.C. Conservative Leader John Rustad, who are midway through an election campaign.

Police in major cities stepped up protections during the anniversary.

Children were dropped off by parents at the Talmud Torah elementary school in Vancouver Monday morning under the gaze of police in bulletproof vests and at least one police dog.

Allie Saks, who has two children attending Talmud Torah, broke down in tears when asked about the police presence and parents’ unease.

“It’s hard to drop your kid off somewhere where you have to see police in front,” Saks said. “And it’s emotional for all of us. We’re all in a state of grief today and for the whole year — until our hostages come home.”

Vancouver Police Chief Const. Adam Palmer said last week that protests posed a “significant” risk of disorder on Monday, and officers trained specifically for large-scale events were being deployed.

Pro-Palestinian group Samidoun was planning a Vancouver rally which it promoted by referring to the Oct. 7 attacks as “Al-Aqsa Flood,” the Hamas code name for the operation.

A Toronto police van was parked out front of a Hebrew day school along Bathurst Street in one of the city’s most recognizably Jewish neighbourhoods. On the corner, a large poster called for the return of hostages.

Just up the road, at the Sherman Campus, a sprawling hub of Jewish groups and agencies, preparations were being made for a memorial event planned for Monday night.

A spokesperson for the UJA Federation of Greater Toronto, which was hosting the evening event, said it was important to gather to “remember all the lives that were tragically lost on Oct. 7 in Israel, but also to recognize that this situation is still a live situation.”

“This is not an opportunity where we are remembering something that happened. We still have more than 100 hostages, including family members of Canadians, who are in Gaza being held by Hamas,” said Sara Lefton, the organization’s chief development officer.

Some victims’ families also launched legal action on Monday over the attack.

Tiferet Lapidot’s father, along with another Canadian who lost family members in the attack, filed a claim in Ontario Superior Court seeking $250 million in damages under Canada’s Justice for Victims of Terrorism Act, plus an additional $100 million.

The claim lists Hamas, various Palestinian organizations, the leaders of Iran and Syria and several Canadian individuals and groups among the defendants.

It alleges all the defendants are in some way responsible or liable for the losses and damages caused by the deaths. None of the allegations have been tested in court.

Family members said the last time they heard from Lapidot was in a phone call from the Supernova music festival near Israel’s border with the Gaza Strip, where Hamas launched its attack.

“She called her mother at nine o’clock in the morning, telling her that she loves her and they’re shooting youngsters all around,” her uncle, Harel Lapidot, said Monday at a Toronto event marking the anniversary.

A year later, the family’s grief over the loss of the young woman he described as their “sunshine” is “getting worse day by day,” her uncle said. She was one of at least eight people with ties to Canada who died that day.

“It was the most horrific thing for us as a family to lose Tiferet. Tiferet was a happy young lady … that was just dancing at a festival,” he said.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau told an event in Ottawa that members of the Jewish community in Canada continue to feel the effects of Oct. 7, including when people wave the flags of Hamas and Hezbollah and fellow Canadians dismiss their pain.

“You relive it when the term Zionist is tossed around as a profanity, a label for something other than what it truly means, believing in the right of Jewish people, like all people, to determine their future,” he said.

Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre also addressed the crowd and criticized the government’s positions on the war and its handling of protests and attacks on Jewish institutions.

“This ideology that seeks to divide our people based on race and ethnicity that has led to these horrifying outbursts of hatred are not from the bottom up. They are from the top down,” he said.

Monday’s events took place against a backdrop of escalating hostilities in the Middle East.

Hamas, which remains in control of the bombarded Gaza Strip, marked the anniversary by firing a barrage of rockets at Tel Aviv.

Lebanon’s Hezbollah vowed to keep up its own rocket fire despite recent losses in southern Lebanon, where Israel has been mounting a ground incursion.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Oct. 7, 2024.

— With files from Jordan Omstead in Toronto, Sidhartha Banerjee in Montreal, Chuck Chiang in Vancouver and The Associated Press.