For Ontarians outside Toronto and the GTA, this has been a long-awaited week. At last, the provincial government has granted us a few additional personal freedoms. On Friday, we will be able to get a salon tan, a tattoo, even a piercing. We can shop in malls, ever so carefully. Restaurant patios will open, but let’s hope it doesn’t rain too often. For those climbing the walls from boredom, there is the chance to modestly alleviate it by participating in paintball, mini-golf, archery and go-kart racing.
Importantly, there is the return of the haircut. Please note that while the hair on your head can be cut, beard and eyebrow trimming services are not allowed. Only senior officials in the Ministry of Grooming can understand the reasoning behind this important distinction.
While acknowledging that the euphoria created by all these new opportunities is something that Torontonians and their neighbours can only dream about, one quickly reaches the realization that this pale imitation of our former lives still leaves a great deal to be desired. After all the anticipation, the phase two reopening is like opening a long-anticipated Christmas present and discovering that it is just a pair of practical socks.
Even the fabled phase three of the Ontario reopening will still leave a province where many everyday activities are more difficult, more expensive or simply non-existent.
Restaurants are the most obvious example of the problem. People go to a restaurant not just because they are hungry, but to have a good time. Now, it will be welcome to your neighbourhood bistro, mind if we take your temperature? Wear your mask. Wait outside until you are called. Stay away from everyone. Don’t touch anything unless you absolutely have to.
The level of safety that is perceived as necessary is such that it takes the fun out of the experience. Worse, from the restaurant’s point of view, is that physically distanced seating will be so limited that they won’t be able to make any profit.
The COVID-19 precautions businesses now face drive up costs at a time when revenue is down. That’s not to say the precautions are unnecessary, but that they are unaffordable. It’s easy for government to tell businesses they can reopen, but if they can’t at least break even, then they will go broke or continue to hang on with heavy government subsidies. Neither is desirable.
The two things that have sustained hope are the gradual economic restart and the prospect of a vaccine
Everything is going to cost more and Ontarians will be paying for it, either directly or through the higher taxes that are sure to follow the pandemic spending spree. It’s actually best if the tax increases come soon. The alternative is to put the pandemic debt on government’s tab and make it a legacy for the next generation.
Even in Ontario’s third phase of reopening, what one might call the fun sector will be either absent or severely constrained. Movie theatres and concerts will be allowed, but with the seating restrictions that guarantee losses. The idea that people might be able to attend a sporting event is so unimaginable that it’s not even in the government’s plan.
It’s difficult to believe that Ontario’s pandemic lockdown is still not quite three months old. The two things that have sustained hope are the gradual economic restart and the prospect of a vaccine. Not to be overly discouraging, but the restart with strict safety rules will leave us with a crippled economy and hundreds of thousands of people struggling to get by. While people speak of a vaccine in 12 to 18 months, there has never been a successful coronavirus vaccine and developing one is exceedingly complex.
[embedded content]
So what do we do? First, we acknowledge that anything less than a fully functioning economy is financially unsustainable for individuals, businesses and governments. That has to be our goal, but the plan put forward by the provincial government is far less than that. It’s an inadequate end game.
We can restore our economy by gradually increasing our tolerance to risk and we do that by carefully assessing the effects of the staged reopening. Ontario’s daily COVID-19 case numbers are coming down nicely, even though testing is at record rates. Future case numbers will be an indicator of the effect of reopening, but we need to look beyond that.
The most important numbers to watch are not case numbers, but numbers of deaths and capacity of the health-care system. Hospitalization numbers continue to decline and mortality numbers are low, just .017 per cent of the population.
Ultimately, Ontarians will have to accept more risk if they want a normal life. We are some way from that point now, but it should be the target.
Randall Denley is an Ottawa political commentator and former Ontario PC candidate. Contact him at randalldenley1@gmail.com