What began for Eric and Kerri Langer as a quick trip to check on their New York property turned into a week-long struggle to reverse an unexpected quarantine order, all because their ArriveCAN app didn’t load when they tried to cross the border on their return home.
Their “ridiculous” problem ended with a “ridiculous” solution, the fully vaccinated Cobourg, Ont., couple said. On Thursday they found themselves driving back into the United States and then re-entering Canada so they could re-show their proof of vaccination papers to an officer.
The second time around, their papers were accepted and they were no longer required to quarantine.
“Look it, we had to fight stupid with stupid here,” Eric Langer said while driving home afterwards.
The couple’s experience is one of many that CBC News has reported on in recent months that demonstrate ongoing confusion and skepticism surrounding Canada’s land border rules.
This past summer, several travellers reported getting robocalls reminding them to quarantine even if they weren’t required to. One person was fined more than $6,000 when he forgot his email password at the border and was unable to retrieve his negative test results. And in October, a Toronto man said he’d been sent other people’s test results and personal information even though he hadn’t travelled for months.
“In the court of law, we would have a right to defend ourselves,” Kerri Langer said. “Here, you’re guilty and there is no way of proving your innocence.”
‘There’s no information. It’s crazy’
The Langers entered the U.S. last weekend to visit their Lake Placid home for the first time since the COVID-19 pandemic began. They said they made sure to be well versed on Canada’s travel rules and kept the trip under 72 hours so they wouldn’t be required to show a negative COVID-19 test result.
But when they pulled up to the Thousand Islands border crossing to return home Monday morning, the ArriveCAN app with their proof of vaccination wouldn’t load on Eric’s phone, he said. The officer refused to look at their printed documents and ordered they quarantine for two weeks.
As a teacher at a short-staffed elementary school, Kerri said taking that much time off work wasn’t an option. So, when they got home, Eric started making calls to elected officials, the Public Health Agency of Canada and the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA).
“The resolution should have been somebody calls to verify that we are indeed vaccinated,” Eric said. “Boom. The quarantine is lifted. But there’s nobody. There’s no information. It’s crazy.”
After a few days of persistent phone calls, he said he reached a CBSA supervisor who advised that even though they were under a quarantine order, they were allowed to drive into the U.S. and back again — a rule the agency confirmed to CBC News. If they showed an officer the right documentation, the order would be lifted.
“I think the ridiculousness of today is that I couldn’t get in my car and drive to the [grocery store], but I could get into my car and drive across the border and that was OK,” Kerri said.
Kelly Sundberg, an associate professor in the department of economics, justice, and policy studies at Mount Royal University in Calgary who spent 15 years as a CBSA officer, said this case exemplifies the issues raised in the auditor general’s scathing report this week about the federal government’s handling of its border during the pandemic.
“The rules change. How they’re enforced changes. Interpretation of these rules is dependent on the officer’s location, and all in all, it really does nothing to safeguard or protect Canadians,” Sundberg said.
“What it does do is cause extreme frustration and understandable hard feelings.”
CBSA accepting in-person documents, minister says
Although the Langers aren’t sure why their second time around was a success, a couple of factors were at play this week that could provide an explanation.
Eric said when they were crossing back into Canada on Thursday they were also informed by an officer that the ArriveCAN app was down and therefore printed documentation was acceptable, regardless of the rules.
The Public Health Agency of Canada confirmed that the service disruption will run until Tuesday, as the app is undergoing a scheduled update.
Also, Public Safety Minister Marco Mendicino had faced questions from opposition parties a few days before, on Monday afternoon, in the House of Commons.
“Let us talk about the ArriveCAN app that is supposed to protect Canadians but is actually making things worse at the border,” Conservative health critic Luc Berthold said.
“People are being misinformed. No one is answering the telephone to help them. Seniors without smartphones cannot travel. We are hearing stories of mandatory quarantines for triple-vaccinated people.”
In response, Mendicino said he’d directed CBSA to accept in-person information at the border, as well as on the ArriveCAN app.
The CBSA told CBC News on Friday night that the ArriveCAN app remains mandatory for all land travellers, but they can now show a printed receipt at the border if they don’t have a smartphone or mobile data.
Immigration: Canada border tragedy a sign of what's ahead – CTV News
PEMBINA, N.D. —
The discovery of four people who perished in the cold trying to cross the Canada-U.S. border could put a new twist on the immigration debate in the United States.
The group, which included an infant and a teen, were found Wednesday near Emerson, Man., just metres from the Canadian side.
U.S. officials allege they were part of a larger group of Indian migrants trying to cross into the U.S. from Canada.
Border expert Kathryn Bryk Friedman, a University at Buffalo law professor, calls it a troubling sign that the country’s immigration challenges are getting worse.
Friedman says the discovery is likely a “warning shot” that more people are willing to put their lives on the line to enter the U.S., even on foot in the dead of winter.
Florida resident Steve Shand is to appear in court Monday in Minneapolis to face human smuggling charges.
“I do think it’s a warning shot,” said Friedman, who remarked about the enduring appeal life in the U.S. seems to hold for people all around the world.
Indeed, the crush of South American migrants at the U.S.-Mexico border has become a defining characteristic of American politics in recent years, most notably during the tenure of former president Donald Trump.
Nor is Canada a stranger to the problem: thousands of asylum seekers crossed the border in Quebec each year while Trump was in office, though the numbers have dropped precipitously since then.
But an organized effort to sneak groups of people into the U.S. from Canada is a new one on Friedman.
“It just demonstrates the allure still — maybe the enduring allure — of trying to get to the United States. It’s really kind of fascinating,” she said.
But a single incident isn’t likely to prompt either country to seriously rethink the way they manage and defend their shared frontier, she added.
“This sounds terrible, but I think it’s going to take more than four people dying at the border to really galvanize action on the part of Canada and the United States.”
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Jan. 22, 2022.
Omicron's potential peak has experts cautiously optimistic – CTV News
Canada’s top doctor has said the latest wave of COVID-19 driven by the Omicron variant may have reached its peak.
But while the modelling appears encouraging, experts say the news should be interpreted with cautious optimism.
Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Theresa Tam told reporters on Friday that there are “early indications that infections may have peaked at the national level” based on daily case counts, test positivity, the reproduction number and wastewater data.
“I hope we’re at or nearing the peak, but the problem that I have is where we’ve got some uncertainty in the counting now since we don’t do as much PCR testing as we once did,” Dr. Ronald St. John, former director-general of the Public Health Agency of Canada’s Centre for Emergency Preparedness and Response, told CTV News Channel on Saturday.
Due to the shortages in PCR testing capacity, many people who develop COVID-19, particularly if they’re not in a high-risk group and have mild or no symptoms, have been unable to get PCR tests.
“We can’t count people who are asymptomatic, so we have to look at other datasets (like) wastewater concentration, things like that, to try to get an understanding of where we are.” St. John said.
Dr. Jason Kindrachuk, an infectious disease expert at the University of Manitoba, says the news shows “some optimism that things will slowly get back to normal, what they were like prior to Omicron.”
However, Tam said that hospitalizations and ICU admissions are still climbing across Canada and health systems remain under “intense strain.” Kindrachuk says it’s unclear how quickly we might start seeing hospitalizations and ICU admissions start to decrease.
“I think we’ve learned over and over again from the pandemic is that you know, cases rise and then hospitalizations lag behind … and that trend also stays in place when cases start to recede,” he told CTVNews.ca over the phone on Saturday.
“You may be able to slow down that hospitalization rate over time, but you are still going to have pressure on a health-care system that that has been pushed to its limits.”
Dr. Christine Palmay, a Toronto-based family physician, says the hospitalization and ICU data also leave out a lot of patients dealing with debilitating symptoms. She and her colleagues have seen numerous patients who have tested positive for COVID-19 and are struggling with the virus at home.
“They’re not captured by ICU stats. They’re not necessarily accessing ER, but they’re not functioning,” she said.
PROVINCES BEGIN EASING RESTRICTIONS
Several provinces have also reported that Omicron may be peaking or close to peaking. In Ontario, Health Minister Christine Elliott said cases are expected to peak this month, followed by a peak in hospitalizations and ICU admissions. Quebec also reported that hospitalizations declined for the third straight day on Saturday.
Wastewater data in B.C. and Alberta have also shown signs that the virus may have peaked. However, health officials in Manitoba and Saskatchewan say it’s too early to tell.
When COVID-19 cases began to reach unprecedented highs throughout Canada last month, provinces and territories imposed numerous health measures affecting restaurants, movie theatres, gyms, in-person schooling and more. Now, some provincial and territorial governments have plans to life some of these restrictions.
Kindrachuk says these restrictions, on top of the rollout of booster shots, appear to have helped plateau cases. However, as these restrictions start to ease, he notes that cases have the potential to rise again.
“When you start to remove those safety breaks, you have the potential that things could start to build back in the opposite direction. So, we have to do it very methodically and certainly with a lot of oversight,” he said.
St. John says he’s also worried about health measures being lifted too quickly.
“We have to wait and stick to our public health measures as long as possible until we can be absolutely sure that we’re coming out of the woods, and I’m not sure that we are yet,” he said.
Coronavirus: What's happening in Canada and around the world on Saturday – CBC News
Ontario reported a drop in COVID-19-related hospitalizations on Saturday, but the numbers remained high in the country’s most populous provinces, which have been hit hard by the pandemic’s Omicron-driven fifth wave.
Despite drops of 88 and 56 hospitalizations in Ontario and Quebec, respectively, there were still more than 7,300 virus-related hospitalizations between the two provinces.
There was also an uptick in patients requiring intensive care, with Ontario reporting 600 patients in ICUs while Quebec had 275 patients listed — in both cases a rise of 10 patients compared with the previous day.
During a briefing on Friday, Canada’s chief public health officer, Dr. Theresa Tam, said despite signs of stability in patient numbers in some provinces, the toll on hospitals remains heavy, and many hospitals across Canada are under intense strain.
1/4 <a href=”https://twitter.com/hashtag/COVID19?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw”>#COVID19</a> key concerns 🇨🇦 : during the latest 7-days (Jan 14-20), an average 25,821 new cases were reported daily across Canada. While a 28% decrease over the week prior, infection rates are still high and increasing in some jurisdictions. <a href=”https://t.co/T8pCzvGXeO”>https://t.co/T8pCzvGXeO</a> <a href=”https://t.co/mZX1FPrwvp”>pic.twitter.com/mZX1FPrwvp</a>
More than 10,000 people with COVID-19 were being treated in hospitals across Canada each day in the past week, surpassing peak daily numbers in all previous waves of the pandemic.
Federal health officials said on Friday that daily case counts, positivity rates and wastewater surveillance show early indications that the pandemic’s Omicron-driven wave has peaked nationally, but the volume of cases is resulting in more hospitalizations and deaths.
Among the provinces reporting data on Saturday, Ontario recorded 47 deaths linked to COVID-19, while Quebec added 68 deaths.
Provinces reporting on Saturday encouraged people to get their booster shot. Tam acknowledged on Friday that might eventually mean a discussion with provinces and territories about what being fully vaccinated entails.
Federal officials have changed their own terminology, referring to a third dose as being “up-to-date” on vaccinations. Many provinces require full vaccination to access certain non-essential businesses, travel and other activities.
Tam noted that globally and across Canada, the numbers of those who’ve received a third dose vary.
For example, in Quebec, which recently opened up third-dose eligibility to all adults, about 39 per cent have received the added dose. The province’s health minister said it intends to expand its vaccine passport to require a third dose once more people have had a chance to get it.
In New Brunswick, about 61 per cent of those aged 50 and older have received a booster dose.
“We know that people who are fully vaccinated and have a booster dose have much better protection against serious illness or hospitalization from COVID-19,” Dr. Jennifer Russell, New Brunswick’s chief medical officer of health, said in a statement on Saturday.
While the more transmissible Omicron variant has made clear the necessity for the booster, Tam said it’s not time to have a discussion about changing the definition.
“But we will be re-examining those kind of policies going forward,” she said.
What’s happening across Canada
With lab-based testing capacity deeply strained and increasingly restricted, experts say true case counts are likely far higher than reported. Hospitalization data at the regional level is also evolving, with several provinces saying they will report figures that separate the number of people in hospital because of COVID-19 from those in hospital for another medical issue who also test positive for COVID-19.
For more information on what is happening in your community — including details on outbreaks, testing capacity and local restrictions — click through to the regional coverage below.
You can also read more from the Public Health Agency of Canada, which provides a detailed look at every region — including seven-day average test positivity rates — in its daily epidemiological updates.
In British Columbia, due to record-high hospitalizations, COVID-positive patients in hospitals are being placed in the same room with double-vaccinated people who do not have the virus, provincial health officials said.
In the Prairies, a northern First Nation in Manitoba is facing criticism for its lockdown measures after a group of mothers left to buy groceries on Thursday and an attempt was made to prevent them from returning to the community. In Saskatchewan, the chief medical health officer says COVID-19 hospital numbers could go up to as high as 300 to 500 or more in the next few weeks due to the high Omicron infection rate. And in Alberta, a group of Calgary moms is fundraising in an effort to supply 115,000 school staff members in the province with N95 masks.
In Ontario, the head of the province’s COVID-19 science advisory table is calling on the government to change the definition of the term “fully vaccinated” from two doses to three, even though Premier Doug Ford said this week his government wasn’t yet planning to do so.
In Quebec, hundreds of restaurant owners are considering reopening in defiance of public health measures.
In the Atlantic provinces, the test positivity rate in Newfoundland and Labrador dropped from 21.4 per cent on Friday to 15.8 per cent on Saturday; Prince Edward Island registered its fifth COVID-19 death since the start of the pandemic, and New Brunswick recorded its sixth; and Nova Scotia says there are 82 people in designated COVID-19 hospital units, including 11 people in intensive care.
In the North, Northwest Territories health officials say that its modelling suggests the peak of the Omicron wave “may have already passed mid-January” in the territory, and Yukon has confirmed its 16th virus-related death.
What’s happening around the world
As of Saturday, more than 347.4 million cases of COVID-19 had been reported worldwide, according to Johns Hopkins University’s coronavirus tracker. The reported global death toll stood at more than 5.58 million.
In Europe, thousands of people gathered to protest vaccine passports and other requirements imposed by governments in hopes of ending the coronavirus pandemic. Demonstrations took place in Athens, Helsinki, London, Paris and Stockholm.
In the Americas, the world-famous Carnival festivities in Rio de Janeiro will be held in late April rather than the final weekend of February, as the number of coronavirus cases in Brazil spikes and the Omicron variant spreads across the country.
In the Asia-Pacific region, the prime minister of Samoa has placed the small island nation into a 48-hour lockdown after 15 passengers on a flight from Australia tested positive for COVID-19.
In Africa, the World Bank has approved a loan of $750 million US to South Africa linked to COVID-19, aiming to help protect the poor and support economic recovery from the pandemic, the National Treasury said.
Bank of Canada prepares for a long fight against inflation – The Globe and Mail
Immigration: Canada border tragedy a sign of what's ahead – CTV News
Samsung Galaxy A53 5G's leaks confirm four rear, one selfie cameras – Times of India
Silver investment demand jumped 12% in 2019
Europe kicks off vaccination programs | All media content | DW | 27.12.2020 – Deutsche Welle
Iran anticipates renewed protests amid social media shutdown
Health21 hours ago
Patients with COVID in Fraser Health may now share hospital rooms with uninfected – Chilliwack Progress – Chilliwack Progress
Business14 hours ago
Bitcoin value tumbles almost 50 per cent since record November – CTV News
Sports13 hours ago
Olympics-Ice hockey rivals take different approaches to same COVID opponent
Health6 hours ago
Nova Scotia reports 11 people in ICU Saturday, total of 287 people in hospital with COVID-19 – CTV News Atlantic
Health20 hours ago
Why has BC stopped doing contact tracing for coronavirus? – Dawson Creek Mirror
Economy23 hours ago
22 things you need to know about B.C. business and the economy in 2022 – BCBusiness
Sports9 hours ago
LeBron James revisits Miami as Lakers take on Heat
Sports20 hours ago
TRAIKOS: The NHL apparently wants McDavid and the Oilers to miss the playoffs – Toronto Sun