Four EU states block ‘associate member’ label for Canada

Germany, Italy, France and Greece blocked a joint EU-Canada statement on Oct. 27 that would have named Canada the European Union’s first “associate member,” forcing a redraft two days before leaders meet in Montreal, EU diplomats told Euronews and Rapporteur.

The objection matters because the 21st EU-Canada summit opens Thursday, Oct. 29, with a new “Alliance for the Future” as its centrepiece, and the label that European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen floated in September has no basis in the EU treaties. Four of the bloc’s 27 members broke the “silent procedure,” under which a text is adopted automatically unless a government objects before the deadline.

The declaration was due for adoption on the morning of Tuesday, Oct. 27, Euronews reported. A revised draft circulated the previous evening had tried to distance national capitals from the term by saying it was “put forward by the European Commission.” That was not enough for Berlin, Rome, Paris or Athens.

Germany has been among the fiercest opponents of the term, Rapporteur reported. Germany did not immediately reply to a request for comment, and the outlet cited no on-the-record German statement. Diplomats were not named, and their accounts could not be independently verified.

One diplomat told Euronews the concept “does not mean anything, it is not in the treaties.” Another said: “We don’t know what we are talking about.” Some governments want the legal implications studied before the term appears in a political declaration, and Berlin’s position is that members should first define what the package contains and then agree the wording, Euronews reported.

The dispute is about the label, not the substance. Euronews said there is broad agreement on closer cooperation in defence, critical raw materials, energy, trade and border security. A diplomat quoted by Euronews suggested the label may be a way to package what would otherwise be a sector-by-sector exercise.

The pact is expected to be broad. Agence Europe reported that the two sides are expected to conclude a digital trade agreement on Friday, Oct. 30, and that the European Investment Bank and Canada are expected to finalize an agreement to ease European investment in Canadian resources. Canada already contributes 75 million euros to the EU’s SAFE defence loan instrument, and the EU is to invite Canada to join three civilian security and defence missions in Armenia, Moldova and Rafah, the outlet reported.

Agence Europe also said that Canada’s participation in the 90-billion-euro Ukraine loan had not been confirmed, and that the associate-membership question is not expected to be settled in Montreal. Ambassadors on the EU’s Coreper committee were due to reconsider the text on Wednesday, Oct. 28, and the declaration commits both sides to define the concept by the 2027 summit, according to Euronews.

Prime Minister Mark Carney has preferred to call the arrangement an “alliance of the future.” Asked about the term, he said: “What matters is the substance,” Euronews reported. Canadian officials had already played down the label, as we reported earlier this week, when Canada’s ambassador to the EU said the talks do not include full free movement of labour.

The U.S. reaction adds pressure. Rapporteur reported that U.S. President Donald Trump called the idea “laughable” in September and threatened “very heavy tariffs” on the EU, describing it as a “hostile act.” Neither the Commission nor Ottawa had responded to that report, according to the outlet.

For Canada, the stakes are practical. The United States takes close to 70 per cent of Canadian exports, and Carney has said he wants to double non-U.S. exports within a decade, as we detailed ahead of the summit. The summit also falls amid a separate domestic row over Quebec’s role, which we covered in Carney’s feud with the Quebec premier.

Euronews said the new draft is expected from the office of European Council President António Costa. The leaders’ meeting between Costa, von der Leyen and Carney closes the summit on Friday.

If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independent Canadian newsroom with no corporate parent.

Via Euronews and Rapporteur.