Nearly nine of every 10 dollars in anti-money-laundering penalties on FINTRAC’s public list are tied up in Federal Court appeals, a Canada News Media analysis of the list and court records shows.
The Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada lists 93 administrative monetary penalties imposed between Feb. 28, 2020, and July 24, 2026, totalling $239.2 million. As of Nov. 17, 2026, the notices describe 28 of those penalties, worth $208.8 million or 87.3 per cent of the total, as appealed to the Federal Court with no outcome given.
The notices describe 38 penalties, worth $24.8 million or 10.4 per cent of the dollars, as paid in full or being paid. Another 18, worth $1.9 million, are described only as closed, and three recent notices worth $789,030 give no status at all.
One case dominates the dollar figure. FINTRAC imposed a $176,960,190 penalty on Xeltox Enterprises Ltd., which operates as Cryptomus, on Oct. 16, 2025, for 2,593 contraventions, and the notice says the company has appealed. That single penalty is 74 per cent of all the money on the list. Leaving it out, appeals still account for $31.9 million of the remaining $62.2 million, or 51.2 per cent.
The other large appealed penalties include $19,552,000 against Peken Global Limited, which operates as KuCoin, $6,002,000 against Binance Holdings Limited, and the casino-sector penalties against the British Columbia Lottery Corporation ($1,075,000), the Saskatchewan Indian Gaming Authority ($1,175,000) and the Canadian National Exhibition Casino ($199,000), which were the subject of the first part of this series.
A penalty is FINTRAC’s finding that a business broke reporting, record-keeping or compliance-program rules under the Proceeds of Crime (Money Laundering) and Terrorist Financing Act. It is not a finding that anyone laundered money. Every business has the right to appeal to the Federal Court under section 73.21 of the act, and an appeal is not an admission of anything.
When appeals have ended, the record shows mixed results. The FINTRAC list gives an outcome for six appealed penalties. In April 2022, the Federal Court confirmed both the violation and the $31,350 penalty against RE/MAX All-Stars Realty Inc. of Unionville, Ont., in a decision cited as 2022 FC 598. Three other appeals, by a Markham, Ont., credit union and two real estate brokerages in Montreal and Vancouver, were discontinued and the penalties stood.
The other two ended with less money paid. Exchange Bank of Canada was penalized $2,457,750 in November 2024; on Dec. 18, 2025, the Federal Court confirmed the violations but varied the penalty to $1,027,975, a cut of 58 per cent, according to FINTRAC’s notice. Houston & Associates Realty Ltd. of Calgary was penalized $117,975 in May 2025; FINTRAC’s notice says the appeal was resolved on Feb. 28, 2026, and the brokerage paid $63,987.50, or 54 per cent of the original amount.
Court decisions we found in CanLII’s Federal Court database add three more outcomes for penalties the FINTRAC list still describes as appealed. In Norwich Real Estate Services Inc. (RE/MAX Kelowna), 2024 FC 1996, decided Dec. 10, 2024, the court allowed the brokerage’s appeal of a $156,750 penalty for failing to file a suspicious transaction report. CanLII’s summary of the ruling says the court set the penalty aside and ordered it redetermined, finding the director had mixed up the brokerage’s compliance history with the rule that penalties must not be punitive and had not considered what was needed to encourage compliance.
In Montecristo Jewellers Inc., 2024 FC 309, decided Feb. 26, 2024, Justice Catherine Kane dismissed the Vancouver jeweller’s appeal on three of four violations behind a $222,750 penalty, and quashed the fourth violation and the penalty imposed for it. In Austin Jewellers, 2025 FC 908, decided May 22, 2025, the court dismissed the Coquitlam, B.C., jeweller’s appeal of a $66,000 penalty and upheld the amount.
The FINTRAC notices for those three cases do not say what followed the rulings, and a court ruling can be followed by a redetermination, a further appeal or a settlement. FINTRAC is being asked for the current status of each.
Some appeals have been open for years. Seven penalties imposed between March 2021 and August 2023, worth a combined $1.24 million, are still described as under appeal, and we found no Federal Court ruling on the merits of any of them. The oldest is a $206,910 penalty imposed on March 1, 2021, on Magasin Château D’Ivoire Inc., a Montreal jeweller; the court record shows only procedural rulings on what documents FINTRAC had to produce, in 2022 FC 405 and on appeal in 2023 FCA 100, which went against the jeweller.
The others are a Montreal real estate broker penalized $101,227 in October 2021, a Montreal currency exchange penalized $33,000 in March 2022, two Vancouver brokerages operating under the LeHomes name penalized $282,397.50 and $275,385 in 2022, Cathay Pacific Realty Ltd. of Vancouver penalized $206,250 in July 2022, and Global West Realty Limited of Mississauga, Ont., penalized $132,000 in August 2023. In the LeHomes appeal by LaBoutique Realty Ltd., the court refused in January 2025 to let the brokerage amend its notice of appeal, in 2025 FC 45.
Real estate is the sector most likely to fight. Of the 28 penalties FINTRAC has imposed on real estate brokerages on its current list, 14 were appealed at some point, half of them. Money services businesses appealed 10 of 26 penalties, dealers in precious metals and stones four of eight, and banks one of nine. No securities dealer on the list appealed.
Appeals also test how far a business can push FINTRAC for information. On Oct. 8, 2026, the court refused a request in an appeal by Manor Windsor Realty Ltd. of Windsor, Ont., to make FINTRAC produce notices of violation and decisions involving other businesses, in 2026 CanLII 105745. Courts have overturned FINTRAC penalties before: in 2016, the Federal Court of Appeal upheld a ruling quashing penalties against Kabul Farms Inc. because the agency had not explained how it arrived at the amounts, in 2016 FCA 143.
Federal government accounts show how little penalty money has reached the treasury compared with the headline totals. The Public Accounts of Canada record FINTRAC administrative monetary penalty revenue of $2,047,524 in 2021-22, $1,565,224 in 2022-23, $19,751,909 in 2023-24 and $928,191 in 2024-25, according to the revenue tables for 2023, 2024 and 2025. That is $24.3 million over four years, against $33.2 million in penalties imposed in the same four fiscal years according to FINTRAC’s list. Accounting timing means the two figures do not match year by year, and the gap includes penalties under appeal, such as Binance’s.
The real test is still ahead. Penalties imposed in the 2025-26 fiscal year total $203.3 million, the most on the list by far, and $200.2 million of that is described as under appeal. The Public Accounts for 2025-26, which would show how much was collected that year, were not yet posted on the Receiver General’s site when we checked on Nov. 17, 2026.
Under section 73.11 of the act, a penalty is meant to encourage compliance rather than to punish. FINTRAC said in its Oct. 30, 2025, annual report release that it issued 23 notices of violation in 2024-25, “the largest number in its history,” for more than $25 million. FINTRAC is being asked about the status of the appealed penalties and how much of the money has been collected, and this story will be updated with any response.
This is the second part of our series on FINTRAC and Canada’s anti-money-laundering enforcement. Part one: FINTRAC fined six casino operators in just over a year.
How we checked: We downloaded FINTRAC’s public notice of administrative monetary penalties on Nov. 17, 2026, and coded each of its 93 notices by amount, date imposed, sector and status, using the wording of each notice: paid or being paid, closed without saying paid, appealed with no outcome, appealed with an outcome, or no status. Totals use the amounts as imposed. We then pulled the list of every Federal Court and Federal Court of Appeal decision from 2016 to Nov. 17, 2026, through CanLII’s case database, searched the case names for every appellant on the FINTRAC list, and read the decisions available to us in full or CanLII’s summaries of them; a ruling may exist that CanLII has not published, so the count of unresolved appeals is based on published decisions. Penalty revenue comes from FINTRAC’s section of the Public Accounts of Canada, Volume II, for fiscal years 2021-22 to 2024-25; we compared it with penalties imposed between April 1, 2021, and March 31, 2025, according to the list. One notice posted Nov. 20, 2025, gives no imposed date and was left out of the fiscal-year comparison. Our spreadsheet is available on request.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS













