Ontario’s police watchdog has found no grounds to charge a Brantford Police Service officer who kicked a 45-year-old man during an arrest in July, an encounter that left the man with a fractured left knee, but the director also flagged two other officers for not activating their body-worn cameras and said police reported the incident to his agency late.
Special Investigations Unit Director Joseph Martino concluded in a report signed Nov. 12 that there were “no reasonable grounds” to believe the subject officer committed a criminal offence. The full director’s report on case 26-OCI-318 says the injury happened during an arrest on July 10 near Erie Avenue and Veterans Memorial Parkway.
The report says officers were looking for the man because of two outstanding arrest warrants. Earlier that day, officers had gone to his home and tried to have him surrender, but he refused. A neighbour had reported seeing him outside with an axe, the report says.
Shortly before 9 p.m., a tactical officer saw the man walking on a nearby road and radioed other officers. According to the report, that officer approached with an anti-riot weapon in hand, ordered the man to the ground and delivered a forward thrust kick. Two officers then took the man to the ground, and others arrived to help handcuff him. He was diagnosed at Brantford General Hospital with a fractured tibial plateau, a break at the top of the shinbone at the knee.
Martino wrote that the kick and takedown were reasonable because officers had cause to believe the man had an edged weapon. He was wearing a knife in a sheath at his waist, and a backpack he carried held more knives, the report says. Martino also found it made sense to keep him pinned until he was searched and handcuffed.
The report notes that evidence from the man suggested he was kicked and punched while on the ground and that an officer stepped on his injured knee. Martino wrote that video of the arrest “shows no such conduct” by police. He accepted that the broken knee was likely caused by the kick or the takedown but concluded the injury could not be attributed to unlawful conduct. The subject officer declined to be interviewed or to provide his notes, which is his legal right.
Under section 25(1) of the Criminal Code, police are protected from criminal liability for force they use in carrying out their duties if it is reasonably necessary. Martino said he could not reasonably conclude the force used was unlawful.
The director did raise concerns outside the criminal question. Two other officers did not turn on their body-worn cameras, in potential violation of sections 19 and 27 of the Police Code of Conduct, he wrote. He also said the police service appeared to have reported the incident to the SIU late, in possible contravention of section 3 of the code. The SIU was notified at 10:04 a.m. on July 11, according to the report, and the arrest took place the evening before.
Martino said he will refer those matters to the Brantford Police Service for review and to the Law Enforcement Complaints Agency. The SIU said in its Nov. 12 news release that no reasonable grounds existed to believe an officer committed a criminal offence.
The SIU withholds the names of officers and affected persons in its public reports. The report does not include a statement from the police service.
The decision follows other recent no-charge findings. Canada News Media has reported on the SIU’s decision on a Kitchener arrest and on its 2025-26 annual report, which found three of 261 closed cases led to charges. Our earlier look at the unit’s record on fatal police shootings is also available.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS













