Alberta’s auditor general is tracking 102 recommendations that provincial departments and agencies have not yet put in place, and 58 of them have been open longer than the three years the office uses as its benchmark for getting a fix done, according to the office’s own public list.
A Canada News Media review of the 18 ministry summaries behind the list found a dozen entries that trace back to 2015 or earlier. The oldest, a recommendation to improve how the province monitors and enforces the reclamation of sand and gravel pits, was first made in October 2008, repeated in July 2014 and repeated again in November 2019.
The recommendations table published by the Office of the Auditor General of Alberta sorts every open item by ministry and status. Of the 102, the auditor lists 22 as “ready for assessment,” meaning management has told the office the work is done and is waiting for auditors to check it. Another 76 are “not ready for assessment,” meaning the departments’ own implementation plans say the work is not finished. Four are marked “not implemented.”
The office explains that “not implemented” label in its summaries. A recommendation the government previously accepted is moved into that category “because the department has informed the auditor general that it no longer plans to implement it,” and it stays on the outstanding list.
Health carries the largest load. The Health ministry summary, dated April 2026, lists 16 open recommendations, and all 16 are older than three years. Eight come from the auditor’s February 2023 report on COVID-19 in continuing care facilities, including updating a pandemic plan for the whole continuing care sector and developing a staffing strategy. Three come from an April 2021 audit of publicly funded CT and MRI services, and one, a proactive check that people holding an Alberta health care number still meet residency rules, dates to October 2015.
Advanced Education is next with 12, followed by Environment and Protected Areas with 11 and Energy and Minerals with 10. All 10 Energy and Minerals items are directed at the Alberta Energy Regulator, nine of them from a March 2023 audit of how the regulator manages the liability of conventional oil and gas wells. The regulator has reported eight of those 10 as ready for the auditor to assess.
Several of the oldest items have been repeated more than once. Two Advanced Education recommendations on collaboration among post-secondary institutions were first made in July 2013 and repeated in October 2017. A recommendation that the Office of the Public Guardian and Trustee improve and follow its policies and procedures was first made in February 2013 and repeated in March 2022. Recommendations that two social services ministries improve user access controls on their information systems were first made in October 2014 and repeated in November 2020 and November 2024.
The four “not implemented” entries cover three distinct recommendations, because one is counted under two ministries. For each, the summaries set out the department’s reasons as reported by the auditor.
In the Treasury Board and Finance summary, a recommendation first made in July 2014 asked the department to monitor whether ministries follow the standards for the results analysis in their annual reports. The auditor wrote that the department “informed us that it will not be implementing our recommendation,” saying there is no current government directive to do that monitoring and that it does not have the authority to monitor ministries’ compliance.
In the Environment and Protected Areas summary, dated July 8, 2026, a July 2015 recommendation to improve the design of the Mine Financial Security Program is marked not implemented. The auditor wrote that the department “stated it will not make substantive changes” to the method used to calculate the security that mine operators post, and that while the department says the method is reasonable, the office “found no evidence to support these claims.”
The same summary, and the Municipal Affairs summary, both list a March 2015 recommendation to designate flood hazard areas and regulate development in floodways. The summaries say the departments stated they will not implement it “and will instead rely on existing measures to mitigate flood hazard risks,” and that Municipal Affairs declined to provide its risk analyses, citing privilege. The December 2025 assessment sets out that finding in full.
The oldest entry sits in the Forestry and Parks summary, which lists four open recommendations. Three come from the November 2019 follow-up audit of sand and gravel pits, the 2008 reclamation item among them, along with recommendations to collect enough security to make operators reclaim pits and to collect outstanding royalties for sand and gravel on oil sands sites. All three are listed as “not ready for assessment.” The auditor’s stated consequence for the reclamation item is that “Albertans may have to pay reclamation costs.”
Most of the open list is recent. By the original date of each recommendation, 22 entries date from 2025, 23 from 2024 and 20 from 2023, a total of 65 made in the last three calendar years. Some newer reports also carry recommendations from older audits that the office repeated because it found them unfinished.
The office says it updates the three-year status at the start of each fiscal year and removes a recommendation from the list only once it publicly reports it as implemented.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
How we checked: We downloaded the auditor general’s recommendations-to-government page on Nov. 16, 2026, and all 18 ministry summary PDFs linked from it (dated April 2026 to July 8, 2026), extracted the text and listed every open recommendation with its ministry, report and original date, using the “originally” date where the office gives one. Our count of 102 entries matches the office’s published total, and the per-ministry totals, status counts and three-year counts match its table. Quotes from departments are as reported by the auditor in its summaries and reports; we did not ask the departments for new comment because this story reports the auditor’s published findings and status as stated.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS













