Ontario’s Court of Appeal has ordered a new trial on a malicious prosecution claim against the Durham Regional Police Services Board, ruling in a decision released Nov. 13 that a trial judge’s re-instruction made a jury’s second verdict unsafe.
The three-judge panel set aside the judgment on that claim in Sanayhie v. Durham (Police Services Board), 2026 ONCA 813, including $55,000 in damages for malicious prosecution, $3,390 in legal expenses and $5,000 in punitive damages. Justice P. Lauwers wrote the decision, with Justices M. Rahman and L. Brownstone agreeing.
Andrew Sanayhie sued the board and two officers over his arrest at a Tim Hortons in the early hours of Dec. 22, 2015. According to the decision, he alleged wrongful arrest, excessive force and malicious prosecution after he was charged with assault with intent to resist arrest and assault causing bodily harm. A jury heard the case in January 2025.
The jury did not find that the arrest was wrongful or that the officers used excessive force. Its first verdict sheet also found the charges were not laid with improper motive or malice, which is a required element of malicious prosecution. Yet the jury entered the damages amounts for that claim.
The Court of Appeal said the problem began with an inconsistency between the written questions and the trial judge’s instructions. The damages section of the verdict sheet told jurors to answer “without regard for your answers above,” while the judge’s instructions told them to enter zero if they found no malicious prosecution.
The appeal court said the trial judge was entitled to send the jury back, since the first verdict was unclear. It found the problem was how he did it. In re-instructing the jurors, the judge said the amounts they had entered were “presumably based on the finding of a malicious prosecution.”
Justice Lauwers wrote that those words “effectively suggested to the jury that they had meant to find liability because they entered an amount.” The jury returned after about 20 minutes with a second sheet that found malice and set the same damages.
Sanayhie argued that no one objected to the recharge and that the judge’s intervention was procedural. The Court of Appeal disagreed, saying the issue was flagged before the second verdict was received and that the manner of instruction suggested how the jury should decide liability.
The court said a proper re-instruction would have told jurors to enter an amount only if they first found liability, without speculating about why they filled in the first sheet as they did.
The ruling leaves the jury’s findings on wrongful arrest and excessive force in place. The new trial will deal only with malicious prosecution. The board and one officer were the appellants; the claims against the second officer were dismissed earlier and he did not take part in the appeal.
Sanayhie must pay the appellants $35,000 in costs of the appeal, as agreed. The appellants have also asked for $223,162.29 in costs of the first trial. The court gave the parties 14 days to agree or to file short written submissions on that question.
The trial judge’s reasons are reported at 2025 ONSC 3822. The decision does not say whether either side will seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.
The ruling comes as police conduct and oversight remain in focus in Ontario. Canada News Media has reported on the Special Investigations Unit’s clearance of police in 12 of 14 fatal shootings in 2026 and on the rising Black share of Toronto police use-of-force incidents.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS













