At least 10 businesses, groups and individuals have asked the Competition Tribunal for permission to bring their own competition cases since Parliament’s expanded private-access rules took effect in June 2025, and the Tribunal has not yet allowed any of them to proceed, according to a Canada News Media review of the Tribunal’s published notices and decisions.
Two of the 10 applications have been decided, and both were refused. The other eight were still waiting for a decision as of Nov. 18, 2026, the oldest of them for more than 10 months.
The applications are a test of one of the main changes Ottawa made to the Competition Act in recent years. Until 2022, only the Commissioner of Competition could take most cases of anti-competitive conduct to the Tribunal, and private parties could seek permission only for a few practices such as refusal to deal and exclusive dealing. Amendments in 2022 added abuse of dominance to the list, and further amendments passed in 2024 took effect on June 20, 2025, adding agreements between competitors and deceptive marketing, lowering the test for businesses affected by the conduct, creating a route for applicants who show a case is in the public interest, and allowing the Tribunal to order payments to those harmed. Under section 103.1 of the act, anyone who wants to use the new rules must first get the Tribunal’s leave, or permission, before the case itself can be heard.
The Tribunal issues a public notice under subsection 103.1(5) for each leave application it can hear, and those notices are published on CanLII, the free legal database. The 10 notices issued from July 2025 to August 2026 name the applicants and the companies or organizations they want to bring cases against: Alexander Martin against Alphabet, Google and Apple companies (notice dated July 7, 2025); 8X Labs Inc. against Vistar Media Inc. (Dec. 12, 2025); the Samuelson-Glushko Canadian Internet Policy and Public Interest Clinic against Apple (Jan. 2, 2026); the Consumers Council of Canada against Live Nation Entertainment and related companies (Jan. 7, 2026); Whitecap Partnership against Pulse Seismic (April 16, 2026); FV Dry Ice Inc. against Air Liquide Canada (April 28, 2026); a tire-hauling business, All Star Transportation and Tire Recycling, against eTracks Tire Management System (May 14, 2026); Rave Inc. against Apple (May 15, 2026); Guru Organic Energy Corp. against the Pepsi Bottling Group (Canada) (June 5, 2026); and Aleph Meats Inc. against the Jewish Community Council of Montreal (Aug. 24, 2026).
The first decision came on Jan. 13, 2026, when the Tribunal refused Martin leave to bring abuse-of-dominance and competitor-agreement claims. It was the first ruling on the new public-interest route, and the Tribunal adopted a three-step test for it, according to the decision’s published summary: whether there is a substantial and genuine competition law dispute, whether the applicant has a genuine interest, and whether the proposed case is a reasonable and effective way to bring the issue to the Tribunal. It made no order on costs.
The second came on Aug. 26, 2026, when the Tribunal dismissed the All Star application with costs. The decision summary says the applicant’s evidence did not meet the test for an affected business, that the respondent was found to be a potential customer rather than a supplier for the refusal-to-deal and exclusive-dealing claims, and that the applicant did not explain how ending one non-exclusive hauling agreement could harm competition in Ontario.
The pending cases have moved through rounds of procedural rulings. The Tribunal has issued confidentiality orders in at least five of them and has ruled on respondents’ requests to file their own evidence in at least six, including the applications involving Apple, Live Nation, Vistar Media, Pulse Seismic and the Jewish Community Council of Montreal. In the Rave case against Apple, the Tribunal scheduled an oral hearing to deal with both the leave application and a request for interim relief, according to an order dated July 7, 2026. FV Dry Ice was allowed in September to amend its application to add claims under sections 75 and 90.1 of the act.
None of the claims in the pending applications has been tested, and a decision to grant or refuse leave is not a finding about whether any company broke the law. Leave is a screening step meant to keep weak or unsupported cases out, and the Tribunal has said in its rulings that the process is meant to be decided quickly on a written record.
Refusals at the leave stage are not new. In decisions published on CanLII since 2015, the Tribunal has ruled on seven private leave applications and granted one: a 2015 application by Stargrove Entertainment against Universal Music Publishing Group Canada and others. It dismissed applications by Audatex Canada against CarProof in 2015, CarGurus against Trader Corporation in 2016, Luigi Coretti against Garda World and others in 2019, JAMP Pharma against Janssen in 2024, and the two this year. Another applicant, in a 2025 attempt naming Rogers, never got its case started: the Tribunal ruled in March 2025 that the application was not properly commenced and directed its registry not to accept the filings.
The pattern can be read more than one way. The leave test exists to spare companies costly litigation over weak claims, and two refusals may show it doing that job. The private-access rules were also meant to let businesses and consumers act when the Competition Bureau does not, and they arrive at a time when the Bureau’s own figures show it opened eight abuse-of-dominance investigations in 2025-26, the fewest in six years, while complaints rose. The new regime is also young: eight of the 10 notices were issued in 2026, and eight applications have not been decided.
This story is part of Canada News Media’s series on competition and small business in Canada. Earlier parts found that more Canadian businesses closed for good than opened in 2025 and that Canada’s Big Six banks hold 95 per cent of bank assets.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
How we checked: On Nov. 18, 2026, we used CanLII’s case-law service to list every Competition Tribunal document published there with a decision date from Jan. 1, 2025, to Nov. 18, 2026 (89 documents), and every leave decision and section 103.1(5) notice from 2015 to 2024. We counted one application per Tribunal notice under subsection 103.1(5) and tracked each through the later orders in the same case. Outcomes and reasons are taken from the case summaries CanLII publishes with each decision; the full decisions are linked. Applications filed but not yet the subject of a published notice, and any filed with the Tribunal but not posted on CanLII, are not counted, so the total is a minimum. The Tribunal’s own online decisions database would not load its case lists when we tried it, so we could not cross-check against it. No finding of wrongdoing by any party is made in this analysis.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS













