The Supreme Court of Canada ruled Nov. 20 in R. v. Bilinski, 2026 SCC 40, that a new trial must go ahead for Jordan Bilinski, who was acquitted of sexual assault by an Alberta jury after the complainant said he removed a condom during sex without her consent. The appeal was dismissed 7-2, so the Alberta Court of Appeal’s order for a new trial stands. Bilinski has not been convicted, and he is presumed innocent at the retrial.
The nine judges agreed on one point of law and disagreed on another. Justice Sheilah Martin wrote for seven judges, including Chief Justice Richard Wagner. They held that the Court of Appeal was wrong to say a trial judge must always tell jurors they should have “little difficulty” finding an accused knew the complainant was not consenting once the defence of honest but mistaken belief in communicated consent is off the table. Such an instruction “is never mandatory,” the majority wrote, because it risks taking the fault question away from the jury. Judges keep discretion to give it where there is little risk of that.
The majority nonetheless upheld the new trial because of a different error. According to the judgment, the trial judge did not tell jurors that, when they decided what the accused believed, they could not conclude he thought she consented to sex without a condom unless that consent was communicated by words or conduct. The majority said this was a legal error that had a material bearing on the verdict, because jurors could have acquitted on the basis that the accused assumed or thought she was consenting, a route the law does not allow.
Justices Suzanne Côté and Malcolm Rowe dissented. They agreed that the “little difficulty” instruction is not mandatory but would have restored the acquittal, writing that the bar for overturning a jury’s not-guilty verdict is very high and that, in the concrete reality of this trial, the possibility of a different verdict was only an abstract one.
The facts below are taken from the Supreme Court’s reasons. The complainant testified that she told the accused in a text message before he came over that he would have to wear a condom, and that before the third of three encounters that night she insisted again and put a new condom on him herself. During that encounter, the judgment says, he removed the condom and ejaculated. She testified she did not consent to sex without a condom because of concerns about sexually transmitted infections and pregnancy. In a police interview, according to the court, the accused said he removed it because it felt better. He did not argue at trial that he honestly believed she had consented. The court noted there was no dispute that sex with a condom and sex without one are legally different forms of sexual touching, so the jury had to decide whether she consented to the second kind and whether he knew she did not.
The case came from the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta. A majority of the Alberta Court of Appeal had set aside the acquittal in R. v. Bilinski, 2025 ABCA 270, and the Supreme Court heard the appeal on May 22. The Director of Public Prosecutions, the attorneys general of Ontario and British Columbia, the Vancouver Rape Relief Society, the Criminal Trial Lawyers’ Association, the Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund and the Criminal Lawyers’ Association (Ontario) took part as interveners.
The ruling was released the same day as R. v. Degale, 2026 SCC 39, which the majority here applies. In that decision the court held the Crown must always prove the accused’s fault about the complainant’s lack of communicated consent, whether or not the accused can raise the honest but mistaken belief defence. For jurors and trial judges, the practical result is that trials like this one now need a clear instruction separating what the complainant felt from what the accused knew, and requiring that any claimed belief in consent be tied to something she communicated.
The complainant is not named in the judgment, and nothing in this story identifies her.
How we checked: We read the full reasons of the Supreme Court, including the summary, paragraphs 1 to 64 of the majority and the dissent’s overview, on the Supreme Court’s website on Nov. 20, 2026, checked the header for any publication ban or sealing order, and searched our own archive for earlier coverage of the case and found none. The judgment is subject to editorial revision before it appears in the Canada Supreme Court Reports. We did not contact the parties.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS













