Travellers who took a border food fine to Canada’s Agricultural Review Tribunal lost 78 of the 79 cases the tribunal decided on the merits between January 2024 and Nov. 2, 2026, a Canada News Media review of every published decision found.
The fines were for bringing meat, dairy, plants, eggs or, in one case, a live dog into the country without declaring them. The only traveller who won did so because the Canada Border Services Agency could not prove she, and not her adult daughter, had carried three cooked chickens from Egypt. Appeals of penalties issued by the Canadian Food Inspection Agency and other agencies, mostly against farms, haulers and food businesses, saw 17 of 41 decided cases thrown out entirely over the same period.
We read all 128 decisions the tribunal published from January 2024 to November 2026, on its own decisions site and on CanLII. Eighty-six were appeals by people fined at the border. Five were rejected because the request came in too late, and two were interim rulings on whether a case could go ahead. That left 79 final rulings on whether the traveller broke the law.
In 75 of the 78 losses, the tribunal confirmed a money penalty. Seventy-two of those were for $1,300 and three were for $800. In the other three cases the traveller had received only a warning, which the tribunal also upheld. Added up, the confirmed penalties come to $96,000.
The tribunal has said, again and again, that its hands are tied once a violation is proved. In 67 of the 86 border decisions it cited a 2022 Federal Court of Appeal ruling, Canada (Attorney General) v. Chu, which held that its role is limited to checking whether the penalty was calculated according to the regulations. “This means that if I determine that the penalty was properly calculated, I cannot reduce it,” the member wrote in 2026 CART 8, a $1,300 case over branches, twigs and bark.
The law gives travellers few ways out. The Agriculture and Agri-Food Administrative Monetary Penalties Act says a person named in a notice of violation has no defence of due diligence or honest mistake. Decisions we read rejected arguments that the food was a gift, that it was meant to be eaten on the plane, that the traveller was exhausted after a delayed trip, that a relative had mistranslated the kiosk question, and, in 2026 CART 12, that the traveller was vegan and had forgotten the chicken sausages were a present for his daughter.
Meat drove most of the fines. Of the 79 decided cases, 60 involved meat, poultry, fish or dried animal skin, including at least 18 involving pork, ham or pork sausages, 11 involving chicken or other poultry and 11 involving beef. Ten involved dairy products such as milk, milk powder, condensed milk, butter and ghee. Seven involved plants, including apples, fresh green beans, chili peppers, bay leaf plants and garlic bulbs. One involved eggs and one a live dog.
The penalty amount depends on the law that was broken, not on how much food was found. Undeclared animal products, and plant products that travellers failed to present for inspection, drew $1,300 under the penalty regulations, even where the item was 110 grams of prosciutto. The three $800 penalties were for apples, green beans and garlic bulbs imported without a permit or plant-health certificate under the Plant Protection Regulations. In the garlic case, 2026 CART 43, decided Nov. 2, the tribunal noted the penalty would have been $6,000 had the bulbs been brought in to make a profit.
The one thing the tribunal did give travellers was time. In 21 of the 75 confirmed money penalties, it allowed six months to pay instead of the usual 30 or 60 days. Several decisions also told the traveller that the violation is not a criminal offence and that they can apply to have it removed from the record after five years.
The business cases tell a different story, and the reasons are legal as much as anything. Most of the 42 non-border decisions involved livestock haulers, poultry processors and farms fined by the Canadian Food Inspection Agency under animal transport and welfare rules, where the agency must prove more complex facts, such as whether an animal was unfit to travel. A few involved individuals, and two involved Health Canada. Most penalties there were between $6,000 and $15,000. One request was late. Of the other 41, the tribunal set aside or cancelled the penalty in 17, upheld the violation but changed the amount in 11 (nine times down and twice up), and confirmed it unchanged in 13. Among the cancelled penalties was a $10,000 notice against Universal Ostrich Farms, set aside in 2026 CART 7.
The single border win shows what it takes. In 2024 CART 7, the agency relied on officers’ written reports and called no witnesses. The member found that an officer’s narrative report contained details missing from the handwritten notes he took at the time, that the notice carried the daughter’s passport number, and that the agency had not proved who imported the chickens. “The Respondent has the burden to prove each element and where two persons can equally be the importer, the Respondent has failed to meet that burden,” the decision said. It added that food meant to be eaten while travelling still has to be declared if it is not finished before arrival.
The number of border appeals reaching a decision is rising. The tribunal published 24 border decisions in 2024, 27 in 2025 and 35 so far in 2026, which already outnumber all of last year.
The findings matter as the holiday travel season starts. The Canada Border Services Agency’s guidance for travellers says all food, plants, animals and related products must be declared, and signs beside the arrival kiosks at Toronto Pearson warn of penalties up to $1,300. In the decisions we read, the penalty followed from failing to declare or present the item, or from lacking a required permit, not from the item itself. Our holiday travel guide sets out the other border and airport rules, and our earlier analysis of CFIA penalty notices looked at fines issued to food businesses.
The tribunal’s decisions record each side’s position, and we did not contact the travellers, who are private individuals and are not named here. The Canada Border Services Agency’s arguments are set out in each decision; this story makes no finding against the agency or any traveller beyond what the tribunal decided.
How we checked: We listed every decision the Canada Agricultural Review Tribunal published with a 2024, 2025 or 2026 citation (128 in all, 2024 CART 1 to 2026 CART 43) from the tribunal’s decisions site and the CanLII database, then read the opening paragraphs and the order or conclusion of each one to record the respondent, the item seized, the penalty and the outcome. We counted a decision as a traveller case when the respondent was the Canada Border Services Agency or the Minister of Public Safety. We counted a case as decided on the merits when the tribunal ruled on whether a violation occurred, leaving out five late requests and two interim rulings (2025 CART 40, and 2025 CART 46, whose case was later decided in 2026 CART 17). Product groupings are ours, based on how each decision describes the item; one decision can involve more than one product, and we grouped each by its main item. The $96,000 total is the sum of penalties the tribunal confirmed and does not show what was actually paid. Decisions are published after a delay, so cases heard recently may not yet appear.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS













