Ontario’s Court of Appeal has upheld the forfeiture of $99,210 in cash that a gambler brought to the Fallsview Casino in Niagara Falls, in a case where court records show casino and bank reports to Canada’s financial intelligence agency tracked about $11.7 million of his transactions over 12 years.
In reasons released Nov. 17, Justices B.W. Miller, J. Copeland and D.A. Wilson dismissed the man’s appeal of a February 2025 Superior Court ruling that the money was proceeds of unlawful activity under Ontario’s Civil Remedies Act, 2001. The panel had dismissed the appeal from the bench after hearing it on Sept. 8, 2026, and fixed costs at an agreed $15,000. The man has not been charged with a criminal offence in connection with the money, the lower court noted, and civil forfeiture does not require a criminal charge or conviction.
Canada News Media read both rulings in full. The appeal court did not name the man, and neither do we.
The case began on Nov. 13, 2022, when he presented the cash, sorted into five bundles of $20, $50 and $100 bills, to a cashier at Fallsview at about 6:23 p.m., according to the Superior Court decision. Casino staff called the Ontario Provincial Police, who interviewed him about the source of the funds and kept the money. The Attorney General of Ontario obtained a preservation order on April 26, 2023, and then applied to have the cash forfeited to the province.
The evidence leaned heavily on Canada’s anti-money-laundering reporting system. Reports filed with the Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada (FINTRAC) about the man’s transactions between Aug. 2, 2010 and Oct. 21, 2022 included 27 suspicious transaction reports, 179 large cash transaction reports, 209 casino disbursement reports and five electronic funds transfer reports, totalling about $11,720,520, the decision says. Large cash transaction reports filed between Jan. 2 and Oct. 8, 2022 alone showed about $1,996,500 in cash deposits, against the $160,000 a year in income he reported on his tax returns, according to one of the Attorney General’s experts.
Two experts testified for the province, a senior forensic accountant with the forensic accounting group of Public Services and Procurement Canada and a former Toronto Police Service asset forfeiture investigator who now works in forensics at Grant Thornton. They examined 23 financial accounts and identified 25 more that appeared to belong to the man or his businesses but had not been obtained. The accountant found that, to have $99,210 on hand on the day of the seizure, he would have needed to accumulate the 26 cash withdrawals, totalling $104,000, that he made starting on Oct. 7, 2022. The former investigator concluded the cash bore “the hallmarks of monies that were about to be laundered” by converting them to casino chips and game play.
The man’s position, as set out in the decision, was that he is a high-stakes gambler with a gambling problem who has dealt in large sums of cash for 20 years, and that most of the money came from funds owed to him after he took out a third mortgage to help a friend buy a condominium. The accountant said she could not trace any deposit of the mortgage proceeds into his accounts. Justice Phillip Sutherland found the man not credible, called the structure of his transactions and some of his documents “suspect” and ordered the money forfeited.
On appeal, his lawyer argued that the judge had reversed the burden of proof by requiring him to explain suspicious circumstances, focused on the man rather than the money, and misread the evidence. The Court of Appeal rejected all three arguments. The judge “correctly identified the legal test and applied it to the facts as he found them,” the panel wrote, and was entitled to consider the man’s failure to give a credible answer to the suspicious circumstances once the province had proven its case on a balance of probabilities.
The act states that its purposes include compensating people who suffer losses from unlawful activities and preventing people from keeping the proceeds of those activities. The decisions do not say how these particular funds will be used.
The case shows the casino end of a reporting system that has drawn regulatory attention this year. FINTRAC, which receives those reports, has fined six casino operators in just over a year under the federal anti-money-laundering law. Nothing in the rulings suggests the casino did anything wrong: it was the casino’s call to police that started the case.
The rulings do not show where the money originally came from or what unlawful activity produced it; the civil standard required the province to prove only that it was more likely than not the proceeds of unlawful activity. They also do not say whether any criminal investigation is under way.
How we checked: We found the appeal ruling, Ontario (Attorney General) v. $99,210 in Canadian Currency (In Rem), 2026 ONCA 833 (docket COA-25-CV-0513), in CanLII’s list of new Court of Appeal decisions and read it in full, along with the Superior Court ruling under appeal, 2025 ONSC 1148 (Feb. 24, 2025). All figures, dates and positions come from those two decisions; the FINTRAC report counts are as described in the Superior Court ruling and were not checked against FINTRAC records, which are confidential. Although the Superior Court decision names the man, we have not, because he is a private individual who has not been charged with a crime and the appeal court chose not to name him. No publication ban appears in either decision.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS













