Five recent federal penalties against Canadian banks were tied to errors that touched more than 1.6 million customer loans and accounts and added up to about $111 million in customer losses, refunds and charitable payments, according to a Canada News Media tally of the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada’s own case summaries.
The banks paid $20.85 million in penalties in those five cases, which the agency calls summaries of proceedings. That is about 19 per cent of the roughly $111 million the summaries put on the customer side of the ledger. In four of the five cases, the agency said the problem began in 2001 and ran for 17 to 23 years before it ended.
A summary of proceeding is published when a bank pays the penalty proposed in a notice of violation instead of contesting it. Under section 23 of the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada Act, a bank that pays “is deemed to have committed the violation.” The five summaries, posted from June 2023 to June 2026, are listed on the agency’s decisions page.
The largest by customer impact involved the Toronto-Dominion Bank. In summary No. 2, the agency said employees did not properly enter credit card annual fee rebates, so an estimated 255,886 customers did not receive rebates they were entitled to from Sept. 1, 2001, to Oct. 5, 2023. It put the approximate financial impact at $71,723,694.49. TD paid a $6.5-million penalty on July 11, 2024, and the agency said the bank was reimbursing customers.
The second-largest involved the Royal Bank of Canada. In summary No. 5, the agency said that from 2001 to 2024, when a customer reported fraud and RBC moved the card to a new account, certain credits were not transferred. A total of 227,947 accounts were affected financially, and RBC transferred and refunded $22,427,774.30 and donated $299,000 for customers it could not find. RBC paid a $4.25-million penalty on April 17, 2026.
TD appears a second time. In summary No. 3, the agency said a calculation error after customers changed their loan payment frequency extended the amortization of mortgages, home equity lines of credit, personal loans and small business loans without proper disclosure, from Sept. 1, 2001, to Feb. 22, 2024. It counted 160,658 affected loan accounts and a financial impact of more than $12,165,433.57. TD paid a $5.5-million penalty on Oct. 17, 2024, and processed reimbursements between March 18 and May 30, 2025, the summary said.
The Bank of Montreal case, in summary No. 4, involved discounted banking programs for newcomers to Canada, medical and dental students, Indigenous banking clients and a home financing promotion. Customers who applied in a branch were given the wrong start date for a fee waiver and were charged monthly plan fees from 2010 to 2024. BMO estimated 101,091 customers were affected, refunded $3,027,956.44 with interest and donated $601,570.17. The agency noted BMO had received more than 500 customer complaints about the fees. BMO paid a $4-million penalty on April 22, 2025.
The smallest, summary No. 1, involved National Bank of Canada. Its systems did not process interest payments on non-business days, so charges on 920,529 personal loans did not match the original cost-of-borrowing disclosures between Sept. 1, 2001, and Nov. 18, 2018. The financial impact was $772,748.70. The agency said the problem had been identified in 2010. National Bank paid a $600,000 penalty on April 11, 2023.
The penalties were small next to the customer amounts in the two largest cases. TD’s $6.5-million penalty equalled about nine per cent of the $71.7 million in rebates at issue, and RBC’s $4.25 million equalled about 19 per cent of what it refunded and donated. BMO’s $4-million penalty was larger than its $3.6 million in refunds and donations. The maximum penalty for a financial institution is $10 million per violation, under section 19 of the act.
The time between payment and public posting also varied widely. National Bank’s summary was posted 72 days after it paid, and RBC’s 69 days after. TD’s first summary went up 118 days after payment. TD’s second payment, made Oct. 17, 2024, was posted on Sept. 29, 2025, 347 days later, and BMO’s April 22, 2025, payment was posted on Feb. 2, 2026, 286 days later. The agency’s page does not explain the timing.
Fees and fine print have drawn other federal action this fall. Ottawa has moved to ban bank fees on account transfers, Rogers was fined $15 million over its unlimited plan ads, and a $11-million CIBC fund settlement has a claims deadline of Nov. 18.
How we checked: We read the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada’s Decisions and summaries of proceedings page and each of the five summaries of proceedings in full on Nov. 16, 2026. We added the five penalties, the affected counts and the dollar amounts exactly as the agency reported them. The customer total of about $111 million combines different measures the agency used, “financial impact” for National Bank and TD, and refunds plus charitable donations for BMO and RBC, so it is an approximate sum, not a single audited figure. The affected count adds loans, accounts and customers, as each summary counted them, so some customers may be counted more than once. Days between payment and posting use the payment date in each summary and the “posted on” date on the agency’s main page. We did not include the Commissioner’s contested decisions, such as the $5.6-million penalty against CIBC in 2022, because those follow a different process. The records do not show how much of the TD rebate amount had been repaid by the time of posting, or whether every affected customer was found.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS













