Health Canada’s water monitoring program for pesticides is producing useful information but needs clearer rules on when to act, the federal commissioner of the environment and sustainable development said in an audit tabled Oct. 29.
In 2024, the program’s partners collected nearly 4,000 water samples, which produced more than 700,000 pieces of data on more than 200 pesticides, the audit said. Of the 233 pesticides analyzed, 30 exceeded Health Canada reference values for risk to aquatic life, and four of those were in the highest-risk group.
The auditors found the program, set up in 2024, was carried out as intended. Health Canada used its data in 10 re-evaluations and special reviews during the program’s first two years, including for clothianidin, a widely used insecticide in the neonicotinoid family.
The commissioner’s office said the department has draft criteria for when and how to act if concentrations could harm aquatic life, but has not yet set criteria for when a pesticide level may pose a risk to human health. It recommended that Health Canada finalize its aquatic-life thresholds, develop human-health thresholds, clarify what action follows when a threshold is met, and consider the cumulative effects of pesticides on aquatic environments.
The Narwhal reported that for half of the four highest-risk pesticides, Health Canada had not yet started to assess whether action was needed. A department spokesperson told the outlet it was waiting for quality-checked 2025 data. The Narwhal also reported that the clothianidin limit was exceeded 360 times in 2024, more than for any other pesticide, at sites in Prince Edward Island and Ontario, and that the department agreed to draft the human-health thresholds by June 2027, then consult the public.
The audit lands as Parliament revisits the rules that govern pesticides. The Narwhal reported that Bill C-30, passed in June, lets cabinet approve a pesticide even after Health Canada concludes its environmental risks are unacceptable, if ministers decide it is needed for economic or food security. Bill C-31, which is still before Parliament, would end the requirement that every pesticide be fully re-evaluated at least once every 15 years.
The health minister’s press secretary, Alexandre Bergeron, told The Narwhal that cabinet has not yet used the new power to approve a pesticide. A House of Commons petition against the two bills closed with 21,410 signatures, the outlet reported.
Pesticide questions have come up in our own coverage before, including a berry brand that exceeded pesticide limits without a recall and Mi’kmaw leaders’ fight over spraying near Bear River, N.S.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS













