
On March 27, 2019, a University of Toronto criminologist gave Nova Scotia a number it could not easily set aside. Across 12 years of police data, Black people in Halifax appeared in street check records far more often than their share of the population would predict, and Black men most of all.
The report, Halifax, Nova Scotia: Street Checks Report, was written by Dr. Scot Wortley for the Nova Scotia Human Rights Commission. According to The Canadian Press, it examined Halifax Regional Police and RCMP street check data from 2006 to 2017. African Nova Scotians made up 3.6 per cent of the population but 19.2 per cent of street checks, the report found, which the news agency described as about five times more likely than their population share would suggest. Black women were three times more likely and Black men were 9.2 times more likely, again measured against population share.
What a street check is
A street check, sometimes called carding, is a police officer stopping and questioning a person who is not under arrest and is not suspected of a specific crime, then recording the person’s details in a database. The Canadian Press reported that about a third of the recorded checks involved people who were never charged with a crime.
Wortley told reporters that street checks capture only a small fraction of all police stops, since traffic and pedestrian stops are not counted in the data. He also said the practice had contributed to the criminalization of Black youth, according to the same report. Police argued that street checks help solve crimes and that the disparity reflects where serious violent crime, including gun and gang activity, is concentrated, the Canadian Press said.
Two ways to read the numbers
The figures use different yardsticks, and the difference matters. The 9.2 and five-times findings compare Black residents’ share of street checks with their share of the population. The Nova Scotia Human Rights Commission’s own Street Checks page cites a separate comparison from a January 2017 data release: Black people in Halifax were three times more likely than white people to be stopped by police. Neither figure says by itself why the stops happened. The 2019 report’s argument was that the pattern was large, persistent over every year studied and not explained by population alone.
The recommendations
The report made 53 recommendations, according to the Commission. Seven concerned banning street checks, 24 concerned regulating them if they continued, five covered collection of data on police stops and 17 addressed police-community relations. Wortley recommended banning or strictly regulating the practice.
Nova Scotia’s response moved faster than many expected. The Department of Justice’s 2023 update on the report records a March 28, 2019 ministerial directive that street checks could not be used as quotas or performance measures, then an April 19, 2019 moratorium on street checks of pedestrians and passengers in motor vehicles. On Oct. 18, 2019, the province announced a permanent ban. That same month, an independent legal opinion commissioned by the Commission, written by former Nova Scotia Court of Appeal chief justice Michael MacDonald and research lawyer Jennifer Taylor, concluded that street checks are not reasonably necessary for police to carry out their duties, the Commission reports.
The ban was strengthened by a Minister’s Directive effective Dec. 1, 2021. On Sept. 1, 2022, the Department of Justice accepted all the recommendations of a research committee’s report on collecting race-based police data in the province.
What is still unfinished
The 2023 update shows a mixed record. The ban itself is listed as complete. Some of the broader work is not. A monitoring committee recommended by Wortley is listed as in progress, and the update says its working group is no longer active. A recommendation to address racial bias across the wider justice system points to an African Nova Scotian Justice Action Plan that, at the time of the update, was to be released in the coming months. The province also reports funding for law enforcement training and for police cadet recruitment from the African Nova Scotian community.
The update does not measure whether Black residents are in fact stopped less often since the ban. The Wortley report’s own recommendation to evaluate the ban’s impact is assigned to the race-data research committee. Without that evaluation, the public record shows what the law now says, not what officers do on the street. We have not found a published post-ban figure for Halifax, and we have not tried to estimate one.
The question matters beyond Nova Scotia. We have reported on how Toronto police charged Black people at 3.9 times the white rate, on a tribunal that found Sûreté du Québec officers racially profiled a Black driver, and on how an RCMP race-data pledge skips Halifax. The Halifax story also sits in a longer history, from the last Black-only school in Nova Scotia to the community whose treatment the province has since apologized for.
Sources: Brett Bundale, The Canadian Press, via Global News, March 27, 2019; Nova Scotia Human Rights Commission, Street Checks page; Nova Scotia Department of Justice, Wortley Report Update 2023.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS













