Opinion
Ottawa has not ignored Canada’s banking problem, but nothing it has done so far has stopped six banks from tightening their grip. At the end of August, Royal Bank, TD, Scotiabank, BMO, CIBC and National Bank held 95 per cent of all assets at federally regulated banks, up from 93.2 per cent three years earlier and 90.8 per cent in 1996, according to our investigation of regulatory filings. A market where six firms hold 95 per cent is not the competitive capitalism Canadians were promised, and the federal government is moving too slowly, and too timidly, to change it.
The latest jump came from two deals Ottawa itself signed off on. Then-finance minister Chrystia Freeland approved Royal Bank’s purchase of HSBC Bank Canada with conditions in December 2023, and National Bank said the finance minister gave final approval to its takeover of Canadian Western Bank a year later. The combined assets of foreign-owned bank subsidiaries in Canada fell from $147.5 billion in August 2021 to $32.7 billion this August, because the largest of them is now part of Royal Bank.
The Competition Bureau saw the cost. In its September 2023 report on the HSBC deal, the Bureau said the purchase “would result in a loss of rivalry between Canada’s largest and seventh largest banks” and found high barriers to entry and expansion in many banking markets. It still concluded the deal would not substantially lessen competition, and in any case its view was only advice. Every bank merger needs the finance minister’s approval under the Bank Act, and the Competition Act lets the minister certify a bank merger as being in the public interest. The conditions attached to the HSBC sale, including keeping at least 33 branches open for four years, 18 months of fee waivers and $7 billion in affordable housing financing, were worthwhile promises. They did not restore a competitor.
To be fair, Ottawa has done more than nothing. Parliament changed the Competition Act three times between 2022 and 2024. Bill C-56 repealed the efficiencies defence that let some anti-competitive mergers through, and Bill C-59 added a presumption against deals that sharply raise concentration. A $10 cap on non-sufficient funds fees took effect March 12. Budget 2025 promised to eliminate fees for transferring investment and registered accounts. Budget 2026 proposes a one-year deadline for decisions on applications from new banks, would let a bank reach $25 billion in equity, up from $12 billion, before it must become widely held, would give OSFI a secondary competition objective, would raise deposit insurance to $250,000 and gives the Competition Bureau and Competition Tribunal nearly $130 million.
The trouble is speed and follow-through. Take open banking, which would let Canadians share their banking data safely with rival apps and lenders and make switching banks easier. The Competition Bureau urged Ottawa to embrace it in its December 2017 fintech study. Finance began its review in 2018, and its own advisory committee recommended in 2021 that the first phase launch by January 2023. Parliament passed the Consumer-Driven Banking Act in June 2024, Budget 2025 handed oversight to the Bank of Canada, and draft regulations came out only on June 27 this year. An industry group told The Canadian Press consumers may get access toward the end of 2027 at the earliest, and law firm Gowling WLG noted that Budget 2026 set no launch date. Harvey Naglie, a former Ontario finance ministry policy adviser, warned in a C.D. Howe Institute paper last year that Canada risked becoming “the last G7 nation to implement open banking.”
Payments tell the same story. Payments Canada’s Real-Time Rail, an instant-payment system under development since 2015 and first targeted for 2019, went live on Nov. 9 with eight participants and none of the Big Six, BetaKit reported, with full transaction volumes not expected until the third quarter of 2027. Koho chief executive Daniel Eberhard told BetaKit the system would be largely performative without the big banks.
Meanwhile, the referee has gone quiet. Our analysis of the Bureau’s own statistics found it opened eight abuse-of-dominance investigations in 2025-26, down from 19 in 2020-21, while complaints about that conduct rose to 540, and it recorded no fines or administrative penalties that year. Over six years, 97.3 per cent of 1,338 merger reviews ended with no action. And Budget 2025 renewed the sunset date of the federal banking laws, which drives their regular review, to June 30, 2033.
This matters beyond banking. More Canadian businesses shut for good than started in 2025, with 207,572 exits against 181,233 entrants, and the entry rate for employer firms fell from 15.2 per cent in 2007 to 12.3 per cent in 2023. The records do not show that bank concentration caused those closures, and rates, tariffs and retirements all played a part. But new firms run on credit, and when a handful of lenders set the terms, the whole economy feels it.
Ottawa has better options. It could put a firm launch date for open banking into law, with penalties for institutions that miss it, and set a deadline for the Big Six to send as well as receive payments on the Real-Time Rail. It could give the Competition Bureau the final word on whether a bank merger lessens competition, so that any finance minister who overrides it on public-interest grounds must do so in writing and in public. It could make sure the new presumption against concentrating mergers applies in practice to bank deals, and demand structural remedies, such as selling branches or loan books to rivals, instead of time-limited promises. It could pass the Budget 2026 entry measures quickly, then go further in helping credit unions and foreign banks grow here. And it could require every bank to publish its total annual fees in one standard format, something Budget 2026 itself says it wants.
The banks’ strongest answer deserves a hearing. No Canadian bank failed in the 2008 financial crisis, and large, well-capitalized banks can absorb shocks and finance big projects that small lenders cannot. Nobody should want a competition push that trades away that safety. But stability and competition are not opposites, and Ottawa now says so itself: Budget 2026 wants proportionality and market impacts reflected in how OSFI supervises. Strong capital rules, deposit insurance and a capable regulator are what protect savers. Six banks holding 95 per cent of the assets is not a requirement of a safe system.
Nothing in the regulators’ data shows any bank broke the law, and large market shares are not illegal. But capitalism is supposed to mean that a better offer can win customers from an incumbent. The real test of Ottawa’s competition agenda is not how many measures it announces but whether that 95 per cent starts to fall. So far it has only gone up.
Do you think Ottawa is doing enough about bank competition? Send us your views at [email protected].
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS












