A troop train carrying Canadian artillerymen bound for the Korean War collided head-on with a Canadian National Railway passenger train near Canoe River, B.C., at 10:35 a.m. on Nov. 21, 1950, killing 21 people, according to Veterans Affairs Canada, Valour Canada and a detailed public account of the inquiry.
The soldiers belonged to the 2nd Regiment, Royal Canadian Horse Artillery. Valour Canada said the regiment left Camp Shilo, Man., on Nov. 19 for Fort Lewis, Wash., where it was to train before shipping out to Korea. Veterans Affairs Canada said about 340 soldiers were aboard.
The westbound troop train met the eastbound Continental Limited, CNR Train No. 2, on a sharp curve on the transcontinental mainline in the Rocky Mountains, about a kilometre east of the Canoe River station. Veterans Affairs Canada described the crash site as just east of the village.
The death toll included 17 soldiers and four railway crew, the engineer and fireman of each train, according to the account on Wikipedia. The troop train’s wooden-bodied cars offered little protection, and most deaths were blamed on scalding steam from the troop train’s boiler. Four soldiers’ bodies were never found, Veterans Affairs Canada said.
Sources differ on when the last victim died. Veterans Affairs Canada said all 17 soldiers died that morning. The Wikipedia account said 12 died at or soon after the crash, four more on the rescue train to Edmonton, and Gunner David Owens in an Edmonton hospital on Dec. 9, 1950.
The collision traced back to a garbled meeting order. The Wikipedia account said a dispatcher in Kamloops meant to hold both trains at Cedarside and Gosnell, but the words “at Cedarside” were dropped from the copy given to the troop train at Red Pass Junction. The troop train passed Cedarside without stopping. The line had no automatic block signals on that stretch, the account said.
Valour Canada described the message as a voice message from the area dispatcher, Alfred Atherton. The Wikipedia account called Atherton the telegraph operator at Red Pass Junction and named a separate dispatcher. The two sources therefore disagree on who held which job.
The Board of Transport Commissioners reported on Jan. 18, 1951, according to the Wikipedia account. It did not assign individual blame, and it recommended block signals, better training and checks on how messages are passed.
Atherton was charged with manslaughter in January 1951, Valour Canada said. John Diefenbaker, who became prime minister in 1957, defended him. A jury acquitted Atherton in May 1951 after deliberating about 40 minutes, according to both Valour Canada and the Wikipedia account.
The surviving gunners resumed their journey, and Valour Canada said the regiment sailed from Seattle on April 21, 1951, for Pusan, South Korea. The dead were not awarded Korea service medals, the Wikipedia account said.
The crash is remembered at several sites. A memorial near Canoe River is inscribed “21.11.1950, 2nd Field Regiment RCHA,” Veterans Affairs Canada said. Valour Canada said the regiment holds a memorial parade every Nov. 21 at a cairn in Artillery Park at Garrison Petawawa, Ont.
The collision came the same month as another 1950 Cold War episode in Canadian skies and waters. Our earlier story on the atomic bomb jettisoned over the St. Lawrence on Nov. 10, 1950, looks at that event. Canada’s later role in international military service is covered in our story on the UN naming a Canadian to lead its peace force in 1956.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS










