On Nov. 20, 1969, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled in R. v. Drybones that a section of the Indian Act making it an offence for a status Indian to be intoxicated off a reserve violated the equality guarantee in the Canadian Bill of Rights and could no longer be enforced.
The decision is cited as [1970] S.C.R. 282. It was a 6-3 ruling, according to Wikipedia’s account of the case.
The case began in Yellowknife with a $10 fine. Joseph Drybones, a status Indian, was found intoxicated at the Old Stope Hotel on the night of April 8, 1967, according to the Canadian Encyclopedia and Wikipedia. The sources differ slightly on the details, with one describing him on the lobby floor and the other at the hotel bar.
On April 10, 1967, he was convicted and fined $10 under Section 94(b) of the Indian Act, according to both accounts. Wikipedia says he pleaded guilty without a lawyer and that the alternative was three days in jail.
The Indian Act provision applied only to people defined as Indians, which is what made it the target of the challenge. The Ontario Justice Education Network’s summary of the case describes the section as singling out Indians.
That difference became the heart of the challenge. Drybones’s guilty plea was set aside in the Northwest Territories Territorial Court because he did not understand English well enough, according to Wikipedia, and a new trial was ordered. On June 5, 1967, Justice Morrow of the territorial court acquitted him. Morrow held that Section 94(b) discriminated on the basis of race and was inoperative under the Bill of Rights, according to Wikipedia.
The N.W.T. Court of Appeal refused the Crown leave to appeal on Aug. 25, 1967, and the federal government took the matter to the Supreme Court of Canada. The court heard arguments on Oct. 28, 1968, according to Wikipedia.
Justice Roland Ritchie wrote for the majority, with Justice Emmett Hall concurring in separate reasons. Chief Justice John Cartwright and Justices Douglas Abbott and Louis-Philippe Pigeon dissented, each writing their own reasons, according to Wikipedia. The majority held that Section 94(b) denied equality before the law because of race, contrary to Section 1(b) of the Bill of Rights.
The ruling also settled a larger question. The Bill of Rights was an ordinary federal statute, not part of the Constitution, and some lawyers had argued it could only guide how other laws were read. The court instead found that a federal law that could not be read consistently with the Bill of Rights was inoperative unless Parliament had expressly declared otherwise, according to the Canadian Encyclopedia.
Only Section 94(b) was struck down in the case. Parliament repealed Section 94 in 1971, according to both the Canadian Encyclopedia and Wikipedia.
Sources also differ on how the case is dated. The Canadian Encyclopedia and the Ontario Justice Education Network list it under 1970, the year of the law report, while Wikipedia gives the judgment date as Nov. 20, 1969. A Canadian Press history listing has also placed the decision a year earlier, which does not match the court’s hearing date of October 1968.
Wikipedia notes that the court has not used the Bill of Rights in this way since. Equality rights now sit in Section 15 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which came into force in 1985. Our earlier history feature on Fred Christie’s 1939 bid to be served a beer looked at another early Canadian discrimination case, and our On This Day piece on the Jay Treaty covers an older agreement that touched Indigenous peoples’ movement across the border.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS










