Canada’s biggest news organizations can sue OpenAI in Ontario, the province’s highest court has ruled, rejecting the U.S. company’s argument that a lawsuit over the use of their journalism to build ChatGPT belongs in American courts.
In Toronto Star Newspapers Limited v. OpenAI, Inc., 2026 ONCA 814, released Nov. 13, 2026, a three-judge panel of the Court of Appeal for Ontario dismissed an appeal by six OpenAI companies and ordered them to pay $100,000 in costs, an amount the parties had agreed on. Justice B.W. Miller wrote the reasons, and Justices L. Favreau and M. Rahman agreed. The appeal was heard on April 29, 2026, so the decision came about six and a half months later.
The plaintiffs are Toronto Star Newspapers Ltd., Metroland Media Group, Postmedia Network, PMO Maritimes LP, The Globe and Mail, Canadian Press Enterprises and the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. According to the decision, they allege OpenAI crawled and scraped their websites, used their content to train the large language models behind ChatGPT, and reproduced copyrighted work for commercial purposes. They sue for breach of the Copyright Act, breach of contract and unjust enrichment. None of those allegations has been proven, and the appeal decided only where the case can be heard, not who is right.
OpenAI’s companies are Delaware corporations that were served outside Ontario. They asked the court to set aside service and stay or dismiss the action for lack of jurisdiction. Justice Jessica Kimmel of the Superior Court of Justice refused in November 2025 (2025 ONSC 6217), although she let four of the 10 named OpenAI entities out of the case. The six that remained appealed.
On appeal, OpenAI argued that copyright law is territorial and that the court first had to decide whether the alleged copying happened inside Canada at all, relying on the Supreme Court of Canada’s 2004 SOCAN decision on internet providers. The Court of Appeal said that framework concerns jurisdiction over the defendant, not whether the court can hear this type of claim, and that asking the court to rule on the reach of the Copyright Act would mean arguing the merits, which would amount to accepting the court’s jurisdiction.
The panel upheld the motion judge’s findings that there is a good arguable case on three separate grounds linking the dispute to Ontario. It found that some of the OpenAI companies carried on business in Ontario, including by using web crawlers to gather data located there, making contractual arrangements in the province, using training data generated by Ontario users, holding trademarks and advertising and licensing products to Ontario customers. It found that some of the alleged wrongs happened in Ontario, including use of material sent from Canada and returned in some form to users in the province. And it found that the news sites’ terms of use, which the outlets say scraping breached, were contracts that originated in Ontario.
OpenAI pointed out that it has no physical presence in Ontario. The court said physical presence is not required to establish this kind of jurisdiction, citing the British Columbia Court of Appeal’s ruling in the Equustek case against Google. The judges declined the news outlets’ invitation to broaden the test to cover “active commercial participation” online, saying it was not necessary to decide that here.
The court also rejected the argument that a U.S. court is clearly the better place for the case. Justice Miller noted that the Toronto Star has other proceedings against OpenAI entities in the United States, but those are brought under U.S. law and do not risk conflicting findings on the facts of this case. He agreed with the motion judge that Canadian law applies and that Ontario is the more appropriate forum.
The ruling arrives as other Canadian rights holders turn to the courts over artificial intelligence. In September, the music rights society SOCAN sued AI music generator Suno in Federal Court. The Court of Appeal also noted that a separate question about foreign AI companies and Canadian regulators, in the British Columbia privacy commissioner’s case against Clearview AI, is the subject of a request for leave to appeal at the Supreme Court of Canada.
What the decision does not show is whether OpenAI infringed anyone’s copyright, how much of the alleged copying took place in Canada, or what damages, if any, the outlets could recover. The panel itself noted the motion judge’s point that if the Copyright Act does not reach conduct outside Canada, the scope of the claims could shrink at trial. OpenAI could still seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada, and the case has not gone to trial.
Disclosure: Canada News Media publishes Canadian Press content under a paid licence. The Canadian Press is one of the plaintiffs. Canada News Media is not a party to the case.
How we checked: We read the Court of Appeal’s full reasons, paragraphs 1 to 60, on CanLII on Nov. 21, 2026, and took the parties’ positions and the list of plaintiffs and appellants from the decision itself. We counted the appellants marked in the style of cause (six of the 10 named OpenAI entities). We searched our archive for earlier coverage of the lawsuit using several phrasings and found none. We did not contact the parties; every finding above is the court’s.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS











