Ottawa paid out $2.3 billion in court awards and legal settlements in the 2025-26 fiscal year, and about 89 cents of every dollar went to First Nations or to Indigenous class-action members, according to an analysis of the newly released Public Accounts of Canada.
Court awards alone reached $1.2 billion, the highest total since 2007-08 and almost 17 times the $72.1 million paid the year before. Nearly all of it was compensation for unpaid treaty annuities owed to First Nations on the north shore of Lake Superior.
The Public Accounts list two kinds of payouts. Court awards are amounts a court ordered the federal government to pay. Claims against the Crown are settlements and other payments made to resolve legal claims without a final court judgment. In 2025-26 the government reported 179 court awards worth $1,203.9 million and 1,144 claim payments worth $1,091.5 million, for a combined $2,295.4 million. The year before, the two tables added up to $1,980.2 million, so the total rose about 16 per cent.
The biggest single block was the Robinson-Superior Treaty. Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada paid six First Nations a total of $1,136.3 million as “compensation paid for past annuities under the Robinson Superior Treaty,” under two Ontario Superior Court of Justice files. Fort William First Nation received $320.6 million, Red Rock First Nation $248.9 million, Gull Bay First Nation $183.6 million, Whitesand First Nation $166.7 million, Michipicoten First Nation $151.4 million and Animbiigoo Zaagi’igan Anishinaabek $65.2 million. The department also paid five law firms a combined $20.0 million in court-awarded legal costs tied to the treaty case.
The 1850 treaty promised annuity payments to the First Nations who shared their lands, but the annual amount was frozen at $4 a person in 1875. In 2024, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled in the Restoule case that the Crown had breached its treaty promise to increase the annuities. The Public Accounts show large federal payments flowing from that dispute.
The claims table tells a similar story. The largest single claim payment of the year was $303 million from National Defence to the Okanagan Indian Band in British Columbia, listed as “compensation for environmental damages.” Crown-Indigenous Relations paid $386.1 million to members of the Federal Indian Boarding Homes class action through a trustee, and $155.2 million on the Federal Indian Hospitals class action. Indigenous Services Canada paid $25.5 million to settle claims over the alleged mismanagement of oil and gas resources, including $17.2 million to Montana First Nation and $8.4 million to Samson Cree Nation in Alberta.
Altogether, payments by the two Indigenous departments came to $1,736.5 million, and with the Okanagan payment the Indigenous-related total reached $2,039.5 million, or 88.9 per cent of all court awards and claims for the year.
The biggest non-Indigenous item was the Manuge class action over veterans’ disability benefits, on which Veterans Affairs paid $118.5 million. Correctional Service Canada paid a $38.3 million court award to the federal administrative segregation class action.
One smaller line moved sharply. Payments listed as “settlements subject to publication exemption,” where the Public Accounts withhold the names and details, rose from five payments worth $6.1 million in 2024-25 to 81 payments worth $65.3 million in 2025-26. Employment and Social Development Canada accounted for $35.4 million of that in two payments, and the RCMP for $8.6 million in 49 payments. The records do not explain the jump. It may reflect how departments chose to label confidential settlements rather than a change in the number of claims, and the tables give no case details.
Several of the largest payments settle very old grievances; the Robinson-Superior Treaty dates to 1850. Court awards and settlements are paid from the departments’ budgets or from funds set aside in earlier years, and the Public Accounts do not show how much of the 2025-26 total had already been booked as a liability before the cheques went out.
How we checked: We downloaded three Public Accounts of Canada datasets on Nov. 21, 2026, all updated Nov. 6, 2026: Court awards (every year from 2006-07 to 2025-26), Payments of claims against the Crown, 2025-26 and Payments of claims against the Crown, 2024-25, published by Public Services and Procurement Canada as part of the Public Accounts. We totalled every row by year, department, type and payee, and checked each total twice. “Indigenous-related” means payments by Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada and Indigenous Services Canada plus the National Defence payment to the Okanagan Indian Band. Descriptions in quotation marks are the government’s own wording. The records do not include the court rulings or settlement terms, and this story makes no finding about the merits of any claim.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS









