Toronto-Dominion Bank has lost its bid to get back GST it paid on Aeroplan Miles issued to its credit cardholders, after the Federal Court of Appeal ruled that loyalty points are not “gift certificates” under federal sales tax law.
In Toronto-Dominion Bank v. Canada, 2026 FCA 193, released Nov. 13, 2026, Justice Nathalie Goyette, with Justices David Stratas and K.A. Siobhan Monaghan agreeing, dismissed the bank’s appeal with costs. The appeal was argued in Toronto on Sept. 15, 2025, so the ruling came 14 months after the hearing.
According to the decision, TD had an agreement with Aimia Canada Inc., then the operator of Aeroplan, that let the bank have Miles issued to its cardholders when they made purchases. TD paid Aeroplan an amount for each Mile, plus GST or HST. It later claimed rebates, arguing the tax was paid in error because Miles are gift certificates, and section 181.2 of the Excise Tax Act says the sale of a gift certificate is not a taxable supply. The Tax Court of Canada rejected that argument in 2024 (2024 TCC 50). The decision does not state how much tax was at stake.
The Excise Tax Act never defines “gift certificate,” so the court looked at the ordinary meaning of the words. Justice Goyette concluded that a gift certificate is, by its nature, a gift or present, and pointed to features of the TD Aeroplan program that do not fit. Miles are earned by enrolling, spending on a card and keeping the account in good standing, and the program describes itself as a loyalty reward program. The cardholder agreement lets the bank cancel an earned Mile “for any reason” at any time, and Aeroplan could change or end the program, which the judge contrasted with the idea that “a gift is a gift.”
The court also traced the history of the law. When the gift certificate rules were written in 1990 and 1993, gift certificates were paper vouchers for a specific store, and electronic gift cards did not yet exist, the decision says. Loyalty points, whether old copper tokens, trading stamps or modern rewards, have always been earned through repeat purchases, which the court said is “fundamentally different” from a gift certificate.
TD argued that treating Miles as taxable led to absurd results, such as paying tax on Miles that are never redeemed or on Miles later used for zero-rated international flights. The court said those outcomes flow from a deliberate policy choice by Parliament: as a financial institution whose services are mostly GST-exempt, the bank generally cannot claim input tax credits to recover the tax it pays. A business that could claim those credits would not face the same problem.
TD is the third of Canada’s largest banks to go to court over GST on rewards points, the decision shows. It cites earlier Tax Court rulings involving Royal Bank of Canada in 2007 and Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce in 2019, the latter upheld by the Federal Court of Appeal in 2021 over a dissent by Justice Stratas, with the Supreme Court of Canada refusing to hear a further appeal in March 2022. Justice Stratas, who dissented in the CIBC case, agreed with the result this time. The court said the Tax Court’s reasons in the TD case went too far in requiring a gift certificate to state a dollar value, and noted that a voucher for a free one-hour spa treatment would still be a gift certificate.
The judges deliberately stopped short of defining a gift certificate, calling the task likely to prove unsatisfactory, and asked Parliament to step in. “Until Parliament intervenes, these reasons can go no further than concluding that Miles do not constitute gift certificates,” Justice Goyette wrote, suggesting a 2016 European Union directive on vouchers as a starting point for new rules.
For cardholders, the ruling changes nothing about how Miles are earned or used; the tax in dispute was paid by the bank to Aeroplan, not by customers. The decision does not say whether the cost of that tax is passed on in card fees, and we found no record showing that. TD could still seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada. The court kept the question of the amount of costs open for 60 days.
Our recent analysis of banking records found that the Big Six banks hold 95 per cent of bank assets in Canada.
How we checked: We read the Federal Court of Appeal’s reasons on CanLII on Nov. 21, 2026, including the introduction, the analysis of text, context, purpose and the bank’s absurdity arguments, the closing observations and the conclusion (paragraphs 1 to 59), and confirmed the Tax Court citation through CanLII’s case database. The earlier bank cases are described as the decision describes them. We searched our archive for earlier coverage and found none. We did not contact TD or the Department of Justice; every finding above is the court’s.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS











