Quebecor Inc. said Thursday that a merger of rivals BCE Inc. and Telus Corp. “would not represent a positive outcome for consumers,” a day after The Globe and Mail reported that Bell’s parent company has held preliminary talks with Telus.
The statement, reported by The Canadian Press, is the first public pushback to the Bell approach, which neither company has confirmed. A Bell spokesperson declined to comment, and Telus also declined to comment on Bell’s reported interest.
Quebecor made public on Monday a takeover proposal for Telus valued at about $31 billion, which we covered in Quebecor proposes to buy Telus at $19.45 a share. Telus has said it sees “serious concerns” with the offer and has not accepted it. Quebecor first made a non-binding proposal on June 26 and submitted an enhanced one on Nov. 9, and Telus chief executive Victor Dodig has said the offer undervalues the company.
In its statement, Quebecor pointed to the volume of consumer complaints about Bell relative to other providers in annual watchdog reports, to price increases imposed on Bell customers and to a recently introduced Bell fee that the CRTC is reviewing as a possible violation of its ban on activation and cancellation charges. Quebecor said Telus has also engaged in such practices and was called to order by the regulator. It said a merger of the two “would only exacerbate these practices.”
Quebecor said that since buying Freedom Mobile it has “embodied” a vision of stronger competition. Those are the company’s own claims, made while it is a rival bidder, and the complaints data and the CRTC review have not produced a finding against Bell in this case.
Analysts quoted by The Canadian Press said the Bell approach was not a surprise. Desjardins analyst Jerome Dubreuil said it is “natural” for BCE to “kick the tires” on Telus, given a long-standing wireless network sharing agreement between the two. He said their fixed networks are “very complementary,” but that winning Competition Bureau approval for a combination of two members of the Big Three would likely be a long shot.
Dubreuil estimated that a combined Bell-Telus would control 55 per cent of Canada’s wireless market, compared with 40 per cent for a Quebecor-Telus merger. He said Bell entering the contest could spark a bidding war that forces Quebecor to raise its offer, or leave Quebecor as a “remedy partner” that buys assets the two would have to sell to satisfy regulators. Scotiabank analyst Maher Yaghi said Bell’s entry could force Quebecor to overpay or push Bell to state up front which remedies it would accept.
Any deal would probably face reviews by the Competition Bureau, the CRTC and Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada. Industry Minister Mélanie Joly has said the government “will not predetermine the outcomes.” As we reported in Ottawa says Bureau, CRTC will review Quebecor-Telus bid, those agencies are expected to examine the Quebecor bid. Prime Minister Mark Carney said Wednesday that more competition, lower prices and better service would be key to any decision, and he declined to comment directly on the Quebecor proposal.
The concentration question is not new. Canada News Media’s analysis of regulatory filings in Big Six banks hold 95% of bank assets after two takeovers looked at how consolidation has played out in another sector, and Rogers was fined $15 million over its “Infinite” plan advertising last month, a case that is part of the consumer-protection backdrop to the telecom debate.
The shares moved on the news, according to market reports cited by BNN Bloomberg. Quebecor rose about eight per cent, Telus gained and BCE fell. The companies have not announced any agreement, and the Bell talks remain unconfirmed.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS













