The Supreme Court of Canada ruled Nov. 20 in R. v. Degale, 2026 SCC 39, that the Crown must always prove an accused person knew of, or was wilfully blind or reckless about, a complainant’s lack of communicated consent in a sexual assault case, and it upheld a conviction for aggravated sexual assault against Bevin Kerry Degale.
The nine judges were unanimous that Degale’s appeal should be dismissed, but they split 5-4 on how a section of the Criminal Code should be read. The full judgment is published on the Supreme Court’s website and on CanLII. The appeal was heard on May 21 and came from the Court of Appeal for Ontario.
Degale was acquitted at trial. According to the Supreme Court’s summary of the case, the complainant did not testify and neither did the accused. The trial judge found the Crown had proven the physical act beyond a reasonable doubt but had a reasonable doubt about the accused’s state of mind, because there was no evidence the complainant had communicated a lack of consent to him.
The Court of Appeal for Ontario set aside the acquittal and entered a conviction. The Supreme Court agreed that the trial judge made legal errors, including requiring evidence that the complainant communicated her non-consent when, the court said, there is no legal requirement to communicate non-consent to sexual contact. It said guilt was the only reasonable inference on the evidence and that a conviction was inevitable.
Chief Justice Richard Wagner and Justice Moreau wrote the joint reasons, which Justices Côté, Rowe and Jamal supported. They held that the Crown has to prove the accused’s fault on the question of communicated consent whether or not the accused can raise the defence of honest but mistaken belief in communicated consent.
The disagreement was over section 273.2(b) of the Criminal Code, which says an accused cannot rely on a belief in consent unless reasonable steps were taken to find out whether the complainant was consenting. The majority held that provision only restricts when that defence is available. It does not create a separate route to conviction based on a failure to take reasonable steps.
Justice Martin, writing for herself and Justices Karakatsanis, Kasirer and O’Bonsawin, agreed the appeal should be dismissed but read the section differently. In her view, section 273.2(b) changes the fault element of sexual assault by adding a second, modified objective path to liability alongside subjective fault. The four judges described the law as having moved from a “no means no” framework to an “only yes means yes” understanding of consent.
For now, the majority’s reading is the law. Prosecutors must prove subjective fault, though the majority noted that where the physical act is proven and the defence is unavailable, the evidence will typically allow a strong inference that the accused was at least reckless. Because the court was unanimous on the result, the conviction stands. The judgment does not address sentencing.
The ruling follows other recent Supreme Court decisions on sexual offences and sentencing that we have covered, including its decision not to extend the rape shield to sex work cases and its ruling upholding a reduced sentence in the Cope assault case.
The complainant in sexual assault proceedings is protected by publication bans under the Criminal Code, and nothing in this story identifies her.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS













