Some Nova Scotia public servants with scientific expertise say they were muzzled or pressured to soften their advice on environmental assessments of onshore wind projects, according to a survey run by the province’s auditor general.
Auditor General Kim Adair released the findings Tuesday in an audit that urged the government to strengthen how it assesses new projects. Her office sent the survey to 136 people who work on environmental assessments in government. Thirty-eight, or about 28 per cent, had worked on onshore wind reviews since 2023 and responded.

“For example, individual respondents reported feeling ‘muzzled,’ being ‘directed’ not to suggest terms and conditions, or being pressured to ‘alter or soften’ their comments,” the report said.
The audit also found that reviewers flagged risks that never made it into approvals. In one project, government reviewers identified risks to endangered wood turtle and lichen habitats that the project owner did not address. In another, reviewers raised concerns about increased wildfire risk, but Adair found no matching terms and conditions in the approval.
“It’s concerning when we hear things from government reviewers that they’re being muzzled, or they’re being discouraged from putting their concerns forward,” Adair said at a news conference in Halifax. She said several problems flagged when her office last reviewed the process in 2017 had been fixed by a 2020 follow-up, but “they have backtracked, or have regressed.”
Adair said the Environment Department also does not properly monitor projects after approval to check that they follow the conditions meant to manage environmental risk. She made 13 recommendations, including measurable criteria with clear timelines in approval conditions, a written rationale whenever reviewer input is not used, and checks on the qualifications of outside consultants. The department agreed with all of them.
The stakes are high because the province is counting on wind power to meet its 2030 renewable energy targets. More than 300 commercial turbines operate in Nova Scotia, and as of 2025 they produced about 17 per cent of the province’s electricity. The report said the province’s assessment process is generally consistent with those of other provinces.
Environment Minister Tim Halman said in an emailed statement that decisions are made “with rigour, and grounded in a lens of science, facts and evidence.” He did not directly address the muzzling claims but said reviewers do “incredible and important work.”
NDP member Lisa Lachance said the audit makes clear Nova Scotians cannot trust the process. “People who are the experts, our public servants, are not being allowed to do their jobs,” she said.
The audit follows other recent oversight reports on environmental enforcement, including an audit that found 30 pesticides above aquatic-life limits in water, and comes as Ottawa has ordered a federal review of a Nova Scotia gold mine hub project.
Details come from the auditor general’s report and reporting by The Canadian Press.
If you find reporting like this useful, consider supporting Canada News Media, an independently owned Canadian newsroom.
Follow Canada News Media
Get the day's top Canadian stories and our two daily 60-second news videos wherever you scroll.
X Threads Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok YouTube Pinterest Reddit Substack Flipboard Newsletter RSS













